S130
Psychiatria Danubina, 2012; Vol. 24, Suppl. 1, pp 130–134 Conference paper
© Medicinska naklada - Zagreb, Croatia
IMPACT OF PSYCHOTHERAPY AND ANTIDEPRESSIVE
TREATMENT ON COGNITIVE FUNCTIONS IN PATIENTS TREATED
FOR DEPRESSION
Adam Klasik
1
, Krzysztof Krysta
2
& Marek Krzystanek
2
1
Institute of Psychology, University of Opole, Poland
2
Department of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, Medical University of Silesia, Katowice, Poland
SUMMARY
Background: Depressive disorders are often treated with the use of antidepressants and with psychotherapy at the same time.
According to the literature these two types of treatment may exert a certain influence on brain functioning. The aim of this study was
to evaluate the effectiveness of different forms of therapeutic methods on the improvement of cognitive functions.
Subjects and methods: 60 patients participated in the study. They were divided into 3 groups treated with pharmacotherapy,
psychotherapy or both, respectively. The neuropsychological changes observed as a results of the application of these methods was
assessed with the Vienna Test System (VTS). The patients recruited to the study were treated at the psychotherapeutic subdivision of
a psychiatric ward. Inclusion in the study was restricted to individuals with a diagnosis of recurrent depressive disorder.
Results: The improvement in psychological tests measuring short-term memory and attention was present on average after 8
weeks of treatment and was most prominent in patients treated with both forms of therapy.
Conclusions: The interpretation of the achieved results must be cautious because of the relatively small groups participating in
the study. Further research is necessary to analyze the impact of different therapeutic forms used in the treatment of depression on
cognitive processes.
Key words: antidepressants – psychotherapy - cognitive functions
* * * * *
INTRODUCTION
So far there have been many observations that de-
pressive disorders are associated with the presence of
cognitive dysfunctions. Cognitive deficits are found in
depressive episodes of affective disorders such as major
depressive disorder and bipolar disorder (Hammar &
Ardal 2009, Godart et al. 2010, Kałwa 2011). However
the association between depression severity and
neurocognitive functioning still remains not fully
understood, and the results of the studies related to this
problem are inconsistent (McClintock et al. 2007). It is
hypothesized that there are many different factors e.g.
clinical, demographic and neurobiological, which have
an impact on the severity and profile of cognitive
impairments (Beblo et al. 2011). In the literature there
are a number of reports presenting advantageous effect
of antidepressants on cognitive deficits in depression.
Constant et al. (2005) found out that treatment with
sertraline had a beneficial effect on psychomotor
slowing and on attentional and executive functions in 20
young depressed patients. Improvement of psychomotor
slowing after treatment with sertraline was found also in
other studies (Schrijvers et al. 2009). Partial improve-
ment in the studied cognitive functions was achieved,
and no differences between patients treated with
fluoxetine and reboxetine was found in a study
evaluating attention and memory functions during a
major depression episode and in remission (Galassi et
al. 2006). In another study escitalopram and duloxetine
turned out to effectively improve the deficits of
attention and executive functions (Herrera-Guzmán
2010), as well as of memory and mental processing
speed (Herrera-Guzmán 2009). In our own study we
found that a 3-month treatment with tianeptine led to the
improvement of attention and short-term memory in
patients with mild and moderate depression (Klasik et
al. 2011). In the literature there is a group of available
findings from neuroimaging studies that both
psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy may exert a similar
influence on the neurobiology of the brain. It has been
observed that completion of successful cognitive-
behavioral therapy in a group of 12 patients with panic
disorder may cause reduction of the baseline hyper-
activity in several brain areas and adaptive metabolic
changes of the medial prefrontal cortices (Sakai et al.
2006). Positive changes in brain activity including the
modulation of limbic and cortical regions were observed
in patients with unipolar depression treated with CBT
(Goldapple et al. 2004). Similar changes in brain meta-
bolism were found after treatment either with CBT or
with antidepressants in patients suffering from panic
disorder (Prasko et al. 2004) and from social phobia
(Furmank et al. 2002). In some studies certain
differences in the effect of both treatment methods are
reported. In a study comparing the results of the
treatment with CBT and venlafaxine in a group of
patients with major depressive disorder (MDD) it was
found that CBT modulates cortical-limbic connectivity
and venlafaxine engages additional cortical and striatal
regions (Kennedy et al. 2007). We have already had our
own observations that both psychotherapy and pharma-