Experimental Gas-Phase Basicity Scale of Superbasic Phosphazenes
Ivari Kaljurand,
²
Ilmar A. Koppel,
²
Agnes Ku 1 tt,
²
Eva-Ingrid Ro ˜ o ˜ m,
²
Toomas Rodima,
²
Ivar Koppel,
²
Masaaki Mishima,
‡
and Ivo Leito*
,²
Department of Chemistry, UniVersity of Tartu, Jakobi 2 str, 51014 Tartu, Estonia, and Institute for Materials
Chemistry and Engineering, Kyushu UniVersity, Hakozaki, Higashi-ku, Fukuoka 812-8581, Japan
ReceiVed: September 21, 2006; In Final Form: December 2, 2006
Seventeen superbasic phosphazenes and two Verkade’s bases were used to supplement and extend the
experimental gas-phase basicity scale in the superbasic region. For 19 strong bases the gas-phase basicity
values (GB) were determined for the first time. Among them are such well-known bases as BEMP (1071.2
kJ/mol), Verkade’s Me-substituted base (1083.8 kJ/mol), Et-NdP(NMe
2
)
2
-NdP(NMe
2
)
3
(Et-P
2
phosphazene,
1106.9 kJ/mol), and t-Bu-NdP(NMe
2
)
3
(t-Bu-P
1
phosphazene, 1058.0 kJ/mol). For the first time experimental
GB values were determined for P
2
phosphazenes. Together with our previous results self-consistent experimental
gas-phase basicity scale between 1020 and 1107 kJ/mol is now established. This way an important region of
the gas-phase basicity scale, which was earlier dominated by metal hydroxide bases, is now covered also
with organic bases making it more accessible for further studies. The GB values for several superbases were
calculated using density functional theory at the B3LYP/6-311+G** level. For the phosphazene family the
standard deviation of the correlation between the experimental and theoretical values was 6.5 kJ/mol.
Introduction
Superbasic phosphazene bases have been under extensive
study during recent years. They are used in synthesis;
1-3
aryl
phosphazenes have proved to be very suitable for building the
superbasic region of self-consistent Brønsted basicity scales in
acetonitrile
4
(AN) and THF.
5-8
The possibility to predictably
fine-tune the basicities of aryl phosphazenes by insertion of
various substituents into the phenyl ring, by varying the structure
of the aliphatic periphery or using higher phosphazene homo-
logues, makes this family very flexible for designing molecules
with predictable basicity. Also the gas-phase basicity (GB)
values for some phosphazene bases have been calculated
7-9
and
experimentally determined.
6,10
In our previous work
6
a limited
selection of P
1
phosphazenes was studied. The obtained results
were in part surprising as they implied that the GB values of
aryl substituted phosphazenes, compared to the basicities in
THF, were rather insensitive toward the substituent in the
aromatic nucleus.
To further study this surprising result, a wider selection of
aryl substituted P
1
phosphazenes was taken into the study
described in this report. Also, several attempts to experimentally
determine the basicity change when going from P
1
phosphazenes
to P
2
phosphazenes for two homological series were made. For
the sake of comparison two Verkade’s bases
12
(see Chart 1 for
structures and designations) and three bicyclic guanidine bases
(MTBD, ETBD, ITBD) were also included in the continuous
basicity ladder. MTBD was used as the anchoring point for the
measurements reported in this work.
It has been suggested more than a decade ago that phosp-
hazene superbases could be one of the most promising families
of compounds for extending the continuous gas-phase basicity
scale of organic compounds into the domain of very strong
bases.
11
However, the practical success in realization of this
promise has been very limited to date. To the best of our
knowledge there have been only two works reporting experi-
mental gas-phase basicity data for phosphazene bases,
6,10
both
reporting data only for a very narrow selection of compounds.
This situation is caused by the serious experimental complica-
tions that arise when measuring the gas-phase basicities of
phosphazene bases. The foremost among these is the very low
volatility of most of these compounds making it very difficult
to achieve and maintain suitable and constant vapor pressure
in the mass spectrometer. Also, it is necessary to have on hand
a range of bases with gradually changing basicities in order to
be able to build a continuous “ladder”.
In this work we have succeeded to overcome both of these
complications (see the Supporting Information for experimental
details), and we present a continuous phosphazene-based gas-
phase basicity ladder with the span of ca. 87 kJ/mol from which
around 40 kJ/mol is an extension of the so far existing
continuous gas-phase basicity scale of organic bases.
Experimental Section
Chemicals. Compounds 1, 3, 7, 9, 12, 13, 18, and 23 were
of commercial origin and were used in ICR experiments without
additional purification. Synthesis, purification, and identification
of 2, 4, 5, 8, 10, 11, 14-17, 19, 20, 21, and 24-30 has been
described in previous works.
5-7,13
HCl salt of 6 was synthesized
as described in ref 14. The salt was converted into tetrafluo-
roborate salt by treatment with NaBF
4
in water. The free base
was liberated from the HBF
4
salt by means of MeOK in MeOH.
ETBD (22) was a kind donation from Prof. Reinhard Schwesing-
er (University of Freiburg).
Measurements of Gas-Phase Basicity (GB
exp
). The instru-
mentation, general experimental setup, and conditions have been
previously described.
6
Detailed experimental conditions for
introducing low-volatile bases into the ICR cell are given in
* Corresponding author. Phone: +372 7 375 259. Fax: +372 7 375
264. E-mail: ivo.leito@ut.ee.
²
University of Tartu.
‡
Kyushu University.
1245 J. Phys. Chem. A 2007, 111, 1245-1250
10.1021/jp066182m CCC: $37.00 © 2007 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 02/01/2007