ACTA SOCIOLOGICA 2008
Scientific Productivity, Web Visibility and
Citation Patterns in Sixteen Nordic Sociology
Departments
Inari Aaltojärvi, Ilkka Arminen, Otto Auranen and
Hanna-Mari Pasanen
Department of Sociology and Social Psychology and Institute for Social Research, University of Tampere, Finland
abstract: Science is being published increasingly on the web. In this article, we
explore how Nordic sociology is represented on Google Scholar (GS), what its
output and impact is, and what factors explain it. Our data consist of faculty in 16
Nordic sociology departments in March 2005. The distribution of their publications
and citations is skewed. Thirteen per cent of scholars do not appear on GS, whereas
only 15 per cent have more than 5 publications. Of scholars with at least 1 publica-
tion (n = 240), 75 per cent have at most 10 citations. Both the number of web hits
(web visibility) and citations are influenced by the gender of the faculty member,
type and age of publication. Web visibility, citations and position are mutually rein-
forcing. Departmental effect is greater in web visibility than citations. International
publications have started to dominate the social sciences, international monographs
being particularly frequently cited. The remaining salience of books shows that
sociology is still a distinct form of knowledge. The exclusive use of refereed articles
and direct comparisons with the natural sciences ignore important aspects of the
social sciences. In all, while GS produces findings similar to those in citation data-
bases such as the SSCI, some systematic differences exist. No individual method for
measuring scientific output is objective.
keywords: citation ◆ Google Scholar ◆ Nordic sociology ◆ scientific output ◆
scientific productivity ◆ Thomson scientific ◆ web visibility
1. Introduction
The World Wide Web has become an important source of information in developed countries,
and its importance is also growing in the developing world. Scientific communities are part
of this development. Dissemination of scientific publications via the web is becoming more
common, and scholars in information science have already been discussing the possibility of
a web mention being comparable to a research citation for evaluating the impact of academic
activity (Vaughan and Shaw, 2003: 1314–15; Kousha and Thelwall, 2007: 1056). During the
history of the web, several search engines have been developed to help users find the infor-
mation they need. In recent years, the Google search engine has held a leading position among
web search engines because it covers more text documents on the web than other engines and
is now the most popular among internet users (Notess, 2003; Sullivan, 2006). One of the latest
applications introduced by Google Inc. is Google Scholar (GS) (http://scholar.google.com/),
Acta Sociologica ◆ March 2008 ◆ Vol 51(1): 5–22 ◆ DOI: 10.1177/0001699307086815
Copyright © 2008 Nordic Sociological Association and SAGE (Los Angeles, London, New Delhi and Singapore)
www.sagepublications.com