Functional and time-course changes in single word production from
childhood to adulthood
Marina Laganaro ⁎, Hélène Tzieropoulos, Ulrich H. Frauenfelder, Pascal Zesiger
Faculty of Psychology, University of Geneva, Switzerland
abstract article info
Article history:
Accepted 11 February 2015
Available online 19 February 2015
Keywords:
Development
Language
Picture naming
ERP
Picture naming tasks are widely used both in children and adults to investigate language production for research
and for assessment purposes. The main theoretical models of single word production based on the investigation
of picture naming in adults provide a detailed account of the principal mental operations involved in the trans-
formation of an abstract concept into articulated speech and their temporal dynamics. These models and in
particular their time-course do not apply directly to children who display much longer production latencies
than adults. Here we investigate the functional processes and the temporal dynamics of word encoding in
school-age children and adults. ERPs were analysed from picture onset to the onset of articulation in 32 children
and 32 adults performing the same overt picture naming task. Waveform analyses were not informative since
differences appeared throughout the entire period, due to an early shift of waveform morphology and to larger
amplitudes in children. However, when the sequences of periods of topographic stability were considered, differ-
ent patterns of electric fields at scalp only appeared in approximately the first third of the analysed period, cor-
responding to the P1–N1 complex. From about 200 ms in adults and from 300 ms in children to articulation onset
similar patterns of global topography were observed across groups but with a different time distribution. These
results indicate qualitative changes in an early time-window, likely corresponding to pre-linguistic processes,
and only quantitative changes in later time-windows, suggesting similar mental operations underlying lexical
processes between age-school children and adults, with temporal dynamic changes during development.
© 2015 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Introduction
Both adults and children can produce a familiar word corresponding
to the concept they wish to communicate fluently and effortlessly. Such
a transformation of a pre-linguistic concept into articulated speech
sounds requires a series of cognitive and neurophysiological processes
which have been investigated widely with picture naming tasks in psy-
cholinguistic (Levelt et al., 1999; Dell, 1986) and neuroimaging studies
(Indefrey and Levelt, 2004; Price et al., 2005) on (young) adult speakers.
Although the sequential or parallel nature of the processes underlying
word production is still under debate, there is a general agreement on
the necessity and existence of a minimal set of mental operations
involved in such tasks. When speakers produce a word corresponding
to a depicted object, they first analyse the picture visually and recognize
it before beginning linguistic planning. Word encoding then entails
lexical–semantic processes, that is, the lexical selection or the retrieval
of the word – the lemma – in the mental lexicon and lexical–phonological
processes or the encoding of the phonological form – lexeme – , which
constitutes the input to the preparation of motor plans (phonetic
encoding) for articulation. The time-course of these processes has
been estimated in a meta-analysis of behavioural and event-related po-
tential (ERP) studies by Indefrey and Levelt (2004), and then updated
on the basis of more recent evidence (Indefrey, 2011). In picture nam-
ing tasks, visual and conceptual processes are estimated to take place
during the first 190–200 ms after picture presentation, followed by
lexical–semantic processes (lemma retrieval) until about 275 ms.
Word form (lexeme) retrieval and phonological encoding processes
are thought to be engaged until 400–500 ms followed by phonetic
encoding and motor execution.
These estimates of the timing of the different cognitive processes
have been made for adult word production. They provide a general
framework for studying the dynamics of word production in adults,
although mean production latencies vary considerably across experi-
ments, raising the question of rescaling the duration of processing
stages. Indefrey (2011) suggested that linear rescaling in the case of
faster or longer response latencies is probably not the correct approach
as, depending on the experimental conditions, specific processes may
take less or more time. Laganaro et al. (2012) suggested that variation
in object naming speed in a group of young adults is attributable to a
single underlying electrophysiological process starting around 200 ms
that lasts longer in slower participants. The question of rescaling the du-
rations of processing stages is all the more relevant when populations
NeuroImage 111 (2015) 204–214
⁎ Corresponding author at: FPSE, University of Geneva, 40, Bd Pont d'Arve, CH-1211
Geneva 4, Switzerland.
E-mail address: marina.laganaro@unige.ch (M. Laganaro).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2015.02.027
1053-8119/© 2015 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
NeuroImage
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ynimg