Journal of Oral Rehabilitation 1999 26; 624 – 630
Factors influencing the development of dental erosion in
vitro : enamel type, temperature and exposure time
B. T. AMAECHI, S. M. HIGHAM & W. M. EDGAR Cariology Research Group, Department of Clinical Dental
Sciences, The University of Liverpool, Liverpool, U.K.
were positively correlated (r =0·98, P 0·05) to the SUMMARY The influence of temperature, duration
exposure time. Both parameters were significantly of exposure, and enamel type on the development
and progression of dental erosion has been deter- greater in bovine enamel than human permanent
and deciduous enamel, and in human deciduous mined. Three experiments were devised as fol-
lows. Eroded lesions were produced on enamel than permanent enamel. Lesion progression, as
measured by mineral loss, was in the ratio samples with orange juice: (1) at different temper-
atures; (2) for different lengths of time; and (3) on 2·0:1·5:1·0 for bovine:human deciduous:human per-
manent, and by lesion depth, 1·7:1·3:1·0. In conclu- bovine permanent, human deciduous and human
permanent enamel. Lesion parameters (mineral sion, the erosiveness of orange juice was less
pronounced at a lower temperature, and increased loss and lesion depth) were quantified using trans-
verse microradiography. Both lesion parameters with an increased exposure time. Erosion pro-
were significantly lower at 4 °C when compared gressed twice as fast in bovine permanent than in
human permanent enamel, and 1·5 times more with 20 °C and 37 °C, and at 20 °C when compared
with 37 °C. Lesion parameters increased signifi- rapidly in human deciduous than in permanent
cantly as the length of exposure increased, and enamel.
Introduction
Frequent and prolonged ingestion of acidic foods and
beverages (Levine, 1974; Ja ¨ rvinen, Ryto ¨ maa &
Heinonen, 1991), exposure to acidic environments
such as industries that use or produce acidic materials
(ten Bruggen Cate, 1968; Tuominen & Tuominen,
1991) or gas-chlorinated swimming pools (Centerwall
et al., 1986), as well as illnesses associated with chronic
vomiting and/or regurgitation (Clark, 1985; Ja ¨ rvinen et
al., 1991; Meurman et al., 1994), have all been shown
to predispose teeth to the development of dental ero-
sion. Scanning electron microscopy has been used by
many researchers (Johnson, Poole & Tyler, 1971; Ry-
to ¨ maa et al., 1988; Meurman & Frank, 1991; Millward,
Shaw & Smith, 1995; Grando et al., 1996) to demon-
strate the progressive destruction of enamel structure
with increasing length of exposure to acidic substances.
Meurman & ten Cate (1996) stated that any solution
with a pH value lower than 5·5 may cause erosion,
particularly if the attack is of long duration and re-
peated over time, while ten Cate et al., (1991) used
polarized light microscopy to demonstrate the direct
relationship between the mineral dissolution and the
time of dissolution.
Most acidic drinks and beverages are usually taken
when the drink is either ice-cold, at room temperature,
or warm. Like other chemical reactions, the rate of
enamel dissolution has been shown to be temperature
dependent. This is based mechanistically on the influ-
ence of temperature on the rate of diffusion of chemi-
cal elements through the enamel (Flim & Arends,
1977; de Rooij & Arends, 1981) and aqueous solutions
(Longsworth, 1954), since Gray (1962) reported that
the reaction of enamel dissolution is diffusion-con-
trolled. This suggests that the development and pro-
© 1999 Blackwell Science Ltd 624