International Journal of Scientific & Engineering Research Volume 2, Issue 12, December-2011 1
ISSN 2229-5518
IJSER © 2011
http://www.ijser.org
Suitability of Training Programme Based on
Integrity Traits Identification
Mohamad Farhan Mohamad Mohsin, Faudziah Ahmad, Aniza Mohamed Din, Ku Ruhana Ku-Mahamud, Roshidi Din
Abstract- Training programs for teacher’s development in Malaysia are organized ever year. The selection of teachers to attend trainings
is currently done randomly, by rotation and not based on their work performance. This poses a problem in selecting the right teacher to
attend the right course. Up until now, there is no intelligent model to assist the school management to determine the integrity level of
teacher and assign them to the right training program. Thus, this study investigates the integrity traits of teacher using association rule
technique with an aim, which can assist the school management to organize a training related to teachers’ integrity performance and to
avoid sending the wrong teacher for the training. A dataset of Trainees Integrity Dataset representing 1500 secondary school teachers in
Langkawi Island, Malaysia in the year 2009 were pre-processed and mined using apriori. Mining knowledge was analyzed based on
demographic and integrity trait of teacher. The finding indicates that adaptability and stability are the weakest integrity trait among teachers.
Teachers from the age group of 26 - 30 years are found to have lower integrity performance. However, other demographic factor such as
gender, race, and grade position of teachers were not able to reflect their low integrity level in this study. Findings from this study can be
used as guideline for school management to propose suitable training programs for teacher to improve their integrity mainly on adaptability
and stability traits.
Index Terms— association mining, apriori, big five model, data mining, education training, teacher’s integrity
—————————— ——————————
1 INTRODUCTION
NTEGRITY is a vital trait that everyone must own to per-
fectly complete tasks. This includes teachers who play a
very important role to nation. They are responsible to de-
velop valuable citizens and educate students with a high-
quality education. To teach students mainly at the young age
is not an easy job. Therefore, teachers must have high integri-
ty, and they must establish integrity within the school to ac-
complish the goal. Without the presence of integrity, teachers
will definitely fail to do it [1].
To maintain the high level of integrity, the government
through the Ministry of Education (MoE) has arranged many
programs for teacher’s development through training, work-
shop, and seminar. Currently, the training program is ran-
domly organized to fit the yearly calendar without consider-
ing the right teacher for the right training. The selection of
trainees to attend training is done randomly, sometimes by
rotation and most of the selection is not based on their work
performance. Tailored to [20], there are many training pro-
grams available but there is no systematic way to ensure all
teachers acquire and continue to develop the knowledge they
needed.
Even though teachers are evaluated through the yearly per-
formance appraisal, the inflexibility of the system to identify
less motivated teacher will burden the school management.
Up until now, there is no intelligent model in determining the
integrity level of teachers and assign them to the right training
program.
As a result, this will create difficulties for the school man-
agement to identify problematic teachers and sending the
wrong ones to attend the training. If the requirement of train-
ing program is mismatched with the trainee, there is a high
possibility that the objective of the training cannot be
achieved. Teachers who possess such negative attitudes would
not be suitable for an integrity program. If they were selected
randomly, there would be a mismatch of supply and demand
of needs which would cause failure in the integrity training
programs to achieve their goals. According to several studies,
selecting a wrong person can increase a cost between 30% and
200% of a person’s annual salary. If a role worth $70,000 a year
is filled with the wrong candidate, it could end up costing be-
tween $21,000 and $140,000 – a loss most businesses cannot
afford to make [2]. Even though there is a keen action form the
government to raise the teacher’s integrity, it appears to be a
number of reports that some teachers are unable to perform
their tasks efficiently when they are having a problem with
students and also some of them might involve in crimes [9,
11].
Integrity is viewed as the quality of having an intuitive sense
of honesty and truthfulness of a human in completing task. It is
normally a product of culture with the relation of good traits
and discipline of human beings in all situations [12]. As the re-
sult of high integrity, human beings will be more accountable
and responsible towards his job and struggle to reach his objec-
tive. It is the key of success to everyone, and many organiza-
tions have benefited an enormous performance increase when
their employees own good integrity behavior. As stated in [1]
nothing can work without the presence of integrity. In relation
to integrity, it is stressed out that the integrity among teachers is
critically important [17] and sometimes the solution towards
integrity issues is difficult to be answered. Finding a teacher
with high integrity characteristic is not easy since there is no
agreement on what makes a teacher have a high quality attitude
I
————————————————
All authors are researchers at the School of Computing, UUM College of
Arts & Sciences, Universiti Utara Malaysia, 06010 UUM Sintok, Kedah
Malaysia.
Inquiries can be emailed to {farhan; fudz; anizamd; roshidi; ruha-
na}@uum.edu.my.