Asia-Pacific Conference on FRP in Structures (APFIS 2007)
S.T. Smith (ed)
© 2007 International Institute for FRP in Construction
SEISMIC REHABILITATION OF HISTORICAL MASONRY VAULTS
USING FRPS - A CASE STUDY
S.S. Mahini
1
, H. R. Ronagh
2
, A. Eslami
3
1
Department of Civil Engineering, Yazd University, Yazd, Iran. Email: s.mahini@yazduni.ac.ir
2
Division of Civil Engineering, School of Engineering, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia.
3
Department of Civil Engineering, Yazd University, Yazd, Iran.
ABSTRACT
Collapse of non-engineered historical buildings in seismically active regions of Iran has been reported widely.
Masonry dome and vault, which were built by adobe or bricks with clay, lime/clay or chalk/clay mortar have
often been used in these buildings to cover the roof. Conservation of historical heritage may become necessary in
order to improve their seismic resistance. In this paper, potential failure of a heritage brick vault located in Yazd
city, Iran built in 1935 is investigated under lateral loads. In this building, the piers were built by adobe masonry
whereas the roof vault was made up of clay bricks with chalk/clay mortar. A nonlinear finite element model is
used in the investigation in which the masonry is modelled as an anisotropic continuum using smeared material
models. The material properties of continuum masonry are determined by testing. Finally, the brick vault is
strengthened using CFRP sheets at extrados with different architecture and the failure mechanisms of the
structure before and after strengthening are compared. Results show that when the vault is strengthened at
extrados, the failure mechanism would improve to provide higher ultimate load capacities.
KEYWORDS
Historical buildings, brick masonry vault, carbon fibre reinforced plastic sheets.
INTRODUCTION
Masonry is a heterogeneous material composed of units connected by dry or mortar joints. As units, stones,
adobes and bricks have been used which, can be joined together using mortar. The mechanical behaviour of the
different types of masonry exhibits a very low tensile strength. This property is so important that it has
determined the structural form of historical constructions. The curved structures, i.e. arches and vaults,
represented a significant structural capacity, which were used in the past in spanning wide openings, with adobe
or brick masonry. Indeed, in curved elements, it is usual to find only compressive stresses in a given section and
consequently no tensile resistant materials are required. However, joints can be critical regions in brick masonry
vaults against the severe seismic attack so the contribution of strengthening materials and repair techniques may
be required to re-established their performances and to prevent the brittle collapse of the masonry in possible
future hazardous conditions. Since the mechanisms related to failure of brick vaults under seismic action are not
yet well known, attention should be given to this matter in order to perform repair/retrofitting schemes. Several
researchers reported the weak performance of masonry vault. For example, recently, Maheri (2005) and Mahdi
(2004) noted the poor seismic performance of traditional domes and vault roofs after 2003 earthquake, Bam, Iran.
Retrofitting techniques have been examined in order to improve this weakness. Giordano et al (2001) performed
a numerical investigation in order to assess of the seismic capacity of triumphal arches. Giordano et al (2001),
identified a global mechanism type has been a priori selected for the element, and the critical zones in the arch
which are the left side of both pier bases, intrados on the left haunch, and extrados on the right haunch. Further,
Ascione et al.’s (2005) presented some applications of an adaptive discontinuous finite element model in order to
evaluate the ultimate load and the collapse mechanism of two-dimensional FRP/reinforced masonry structures.
They showed that the loading carrying capacity of the structure increased by FRP/strengthening technique.
In this paper, first the performance and the collapse mechanisms of a case study brick vault belongs to a
historical building located in Yazd city, Iran subjected to lateral loads is evaluated using nonlinear finite element
modelling. Then, the influence of FRP sheets on the seismic performance of the case study vault is investigated.
GEOMETRY OF THE CASE STUDY BRICK MASONRY VAULT
The brick masonry vault examined in this chapter belongs to the Egbal historical complex. This complex
building was built for a textile factory called Egbal between 1932 and 1935. In the recent years, several
restorations were made by the Yazd Science and Technology Park, including recovering and partitioning of the