Investigating the Effects of Temperature, Pressure, and Paraffin
Groups on the N
2
Miscibility in Hydrocarbon Liquids using the
Interfacial Tension Measurement Method
Ali Zolghadr, Masoud Riazi, Mehdi Escrochi, and Shahab Ayatollahi*
,†
Enhanced Oil Recovery (EOR) Research Centre, School of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering, Shiraz University, P.O. Box
7134851154, Shiraz, Iran
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: In this study, interfacial tension measurement (IFT) is utilized to assess the impact of temperature, pressure, and
paraffin type on a nitrogen injection process as an efficient enhanced oil recovery method. The pure and equilibrium densities of
oil in contact with nitrogen are examined to find IFT behavior and gas solubility in oil. The minimum miscible pressure (MMP)
of different systems has been measured using the vanishing interfacial tension technique. The experimental results show that IFT
decreases linearly with pressure, with two different slopes. The results indicate that IFT values decrease linearly with temperature
at different pressure conditions. The obtained IFT values for (hexadecane + N
2
) and (diesel fuel + N
2
) systems are close to each
other. The variation in IFT of nitrogen-paraffin systems by pressure shows a similar slope to that of the N
2
and oil mixture
(diesel fuel) system. The MMP of different systems was observed to decrease with increasing temperature. The results of this
work show that nitrogen injection would be an effective enhanced oil recovery process in high-pressure and high-temperature oil
reservoirs.
1. INTRODUCTION
Enhanced oil recovery (EOR) processes are vital for the energy
industry since oil consumption and its price have increased
sharply in the past decades. Gas injection is one of the most
effective methods recommended for enhanced oil recovery
purposes.
1-3
The injected gas displaces oil in a reservoir under
miscible or immiscible conditions.
4
Miscibility is obtained if
there is no interface between the two phases involved (i.e., zero
interfacial tension (IFT)) or if the two phases can be mixed
together in each other at any ratios.
5
Both of these two
processes depend mainly on reservoir conditions, displacing gas
and oil type. Nitrogen injection has been rapidly developed as
an efficient EOR process.
6,7
Nitrogen could be economically
collected through a separation process from air or through
production from underground natural reservoirs. Under certain
field development conditions, nitrogen injection could also be
economically favorable compared to other gases such as carbon
dioxide and hydrocarbon gases. These characteristics distin-
guish nitrogen as a very cost-effective EOR agent to be injected
into oil reservoirs.
8
Nitrogen injection is usually applied as an
immiscible displacement process, because of the high minimum
miscible pressure (MMP) of typical crude oils with nitrogen. In
other words, a miscible displacement process by nitrogen takes
place at high pressure conditions. Also, the N
2
injection is used
only for light hydrocarbon systems.
7
Thus, high pressure oil
reservoirs with light hydrocarbons would be suitable for
miscible nitrogen injection process.
7
Accurate determination
of MMP is one of the crucial tasks that should be carried out
for a precise prediction of the performance of such processes.
Different theoretical and experimental approaches have been
suggested for the prediction and measurement of MMP.
9-11
The well-known experimental techniques to measure MMP are
slim tube and rising bubble methods. A new experimental
method, known as the vanishing interfacial tension (VIT)
technique, has been developed and utilized to determine the
miscibility conditions of various crude oil-N
2
systems.
12,13
The
advantages of this method are that it is cost-effective and it
takes less time to measure MMP compared to other methods.
The VIT technique is based on the IFT measurement between
the reservoir oil and injected gas at different pressure
conditions. It is well-known that IFT decreases as pressure
increases. The pressure at which IFT approaches zero is defined
as MMP. This can be obtained by extrapolating the IFT vs
pressure to find the pressure matching to the zero IFT value.
13
It should be noted that the MMP is a key important parameter,
since the oil recovery reaches its maximum value at this
condition. Because of different temperatures and oil composi-
tions in the reservoirs, the N
2
injection process enhances oil
either through miscible or immiscible displacement. It is
recognized that during immiscible conditions the interfacial
tension between crude oil and N
2
decreases linearly as the
pressure increases until it reaches the miscible condition at
which oil recovery is critically improved.
14
It was previously
explained
15
that the existence of a paraffin group in a crude oil
has an essential role in determining IFT values between CO
2
and crude oil. The slope of IFT versus pressure also reduces as
temperature increases. However, to the best or our knowledge,
the impact of paraffin groups on (N
2
+ oil) ’s IFTs at different
temperatures and pressures has not yet been investigated.
In this study, the role of temperature and the impact of
paraffin groups in the oil phase on IFT and MMP are examined.
Received: April 23, 2013
Revised: June 22, 2013
Accepted: July 2, 2013
Published: July 2, 2013
Article
pubs.acs.org/IECR
© 2013 American Chemical Society 9851 dx.doi.org/10.1021/ie401283q | Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2013, 52, 9851-9857