Water Absorption of Poly(methyl methacrylate) Measured by Vertical
Interference Microscopy
Mambaye N’Diaye,
†
Florence Pascaretti-Grizon,
†
Philippe Massin,
‡
Michel Felix Basle ́ ,
†
and Daniel Chappard*
,†
†
GEROM Groupe Etudes Remodelage Osseux et bioMate ́ riaux-LHEA, IRIS-IBS Institut de Biologie en Sante ́ , LUNAM Universite ́ ,
CHU d’Angers, 49933 Angers Cedex, France
‡
Chirurgie Orthope ́ dique et Traumatologie, Hô pital Bichat, 75018 Paris, France
ABSTRACT: PMMA (poly(methyl methacrylate)) is widely used to
prepare orthopedic cements. They are in direct contact with cells and body
fluids. PMMA, despite its hydrophobic nature, can absorb ∼2% w/w water.
We have evaluated by vertical interference microscopy if water absorption
can produce a significant swelling in different types of PMMA blocks: pure,
with a plasticizer, with a cross-linker, and in two types of commercial bone
cements. Graphite rods which do not swell in water were used as internal
standard. Hardness, indentation modulus, plastic, and elastic works were
determined by nanoindentation under a 25mN fixed force. Vertical
interference microscopy was used to image the polymer in the dry state and hydrated states (after 24 h in distilled water). On the
surface of the polished polymers (before and after hydration), we measured roughness by the fractal dimension, the swelling in
the vertical and the lateral directions. For each polymer block, four images were obtained and values were averaged. Comparison
and standardization of the images in the dry and hydrated states were done with Matlab software. The average value measured on
the graphite rod between the two images (dried and hydrated) was used for standardization of the images which were visualized
in 3D. After grinding, a small retraction was noticeable between the surface of the rod and the polymers. A retraction ring was
also visible around the graphite rod. After hydration, only the pure PMMA and bone cements had a significant swelling in the
vertical direction. The presence of polymer beads in the cements limited the swelling in the lateral direction. Swelling parameters
correlated with the nanoindentation data. PMMA can swell by absorbing a small amount of water and this induces a swelling that
varies with the polymer composition and particle inclusions.
1. INTRODUCTION
Biomaterials are either synthetic or natural products used after
implantation in the body, to augment or replace a tissue
function that has been lost through disease or injury.
Biomaterials are often studied in the dry state by microscopic
methods such as light, scanning electron or atomic force
microscopy, etc. to characterize the surface morphology that
will come in direct contact with cells. One important
characteristic is surface roughness that is known to influence
cell adherence and spreading.
1-4
Surface roughness controls
protein adsorption and can modify the shape of cells anchored
at the surface of the biomaterial; this has been particularly
evidenced for osteoblasts (bone forming cells) which can adapt
and spread according to roughness geometry.
1,5
However, a
biomaterial’s surface can strongly be modified by hydration in
body fluids which can alter surface geometry and interact with
protein adsorption.
6
To date, little is known about the aspect
and behavior of the hydrated surface of biomaterials and their
relationships with cells and tissues due to the limited available
techniques to study them without dehydration.
Acrylic polymers constitute a large family of biomaterials that
can be used to repair a variety of tissues.
7,8
During the last
decades, poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) and PMMA-
based biomaterials have been extensively used for hard tissue
repair (bone and teeth).
9,10
PMMA was first used as a
biomaterial for preparing hip prostheses,
11
but was popularized
by Charnley in the 1960s as a bone cement for sealing metallic
hip prostheses in the femoral shaft.
12
PMMA is a hydrophobic
polymer that can be used in weight-bearing sites due to its
ability to withstand important mechanical loads and elastic
deformation for prolonged time periods. However, wear debris
can be generated and can induce a giant cell inflammatory
reaction leading to aseptic loosening of the prosthesis.
13
In
odontology, PMMA has been used to prepare dentures since
the 1950s and more recently reliner materials and composite
restoration.
It has been noted that PMMA, although a hydrophobic
polymer, can take up ∼2% w/w of water.
14-17
Water
absorption is known to affect the mechanical properties and
can induce a significant susceptibility to mechanical damages.
Swelling of PMMA-based materials has been seldom studied.
We hypothesized that this small amount of water absorption
can produce a signi ficant swelling depending on the
composition of the polymer and its hardness. In the present
Received: June 3, 2012
Revised: July 12, 2012
Published: July 16, 2012
Article
pubs.acs.org/Langmuir
© 2012 American Chemical Society 11609 dx.doi.org/10.1021/la302260a | Langmuir 2012, 28, 11609-11614