SITUATIONAL PLACES
© The authors 2014
Geograiska Annaler: Series B © 2014 Swedish Society for Anthropology and Geography
1
SituAtionAl plAceS:
REThINkINg gEOgRAPhIES Of INTERCULTURAL
interAction in Super-diverSe urBAn SpAce
by
peter dirksmeier, ilse Helbrecht and ulrike Mackrodt
dirKSMeier, p., HelBrecHt, i. and MAcKrodt, u. (2014):
‘Situational places: rethinking geographies of intercultural interac-
tion in super-diverse urban space’, Geograiska Annaler: Series B,
Human Geography 96 (4): 1–14.
ABStrAct. cities in general and public urban spaces in particular
have re-emerged as important places where strangers from differ-
ent social and cultural backgrounds interact. the growing number
of intercultural encounters assumed by contemporary urban stud-
ies calls for a theoretical examination of how these encounters are
conducted. in this article we therefore critically examine the in-
terplay between cultures, strangers, performances, encounters, and
urban built environments. this means bringing together the the-
oretical ideas of super-diversity, culture in world society, and sit-
uational places. the article argues that intercultural interactions
between strangers in cities – and elsewhere – shape the cultural
conditions of contemporary world society. First, super-diversity is
discussed as a cultural reality of world society. drawing on empir-
ical evidence from psychology, intercultural interactions between
strangers are then demonstrated to be part of ritualized cultural ne-
gotiations. Finally, the notion of situational places is put forward as
the conceptual nexus between these cultural encounters and the ur-
ban environment. this perspective allows the integration of bodi-
ly performances between strangers, spatial and situational context,
and the resulting places of encounter.
Keywords: interaction, super-diversity, situational places, encoun-
ter, culture, strangers
Introduction
in current discussions on urban places, a classic fo-
cal point of urban sociology and geography has re-
surfaced. cities, as valentine has argued, are ‘being
reimagined as a site of connection’ (valentine 2008,
p. 324). rather than being seen as highly segregated,
hierarchically structured spaces that separate, cit-
ies in world society enable encounters between dif-
ferent social and cultural groups; at the same time
cities diminish the possibility of encounters due to
the increasing privatization of formerly public ur-
ban spaces and the increasing segregation of mul-
tiple publics.
in this article we examine from a conceptual
perspective this interplay between interactions be-
tween strangers, their ritualization, performances
and the material cultures of cities as key features of
the contemporary Western metropolis, arguing that
the speciic and temporary relationship of these phe-
nomena in urban space create ‘situational places’
(dirksmeier and Helbrecht 2010, p. 39). Situational
places could be deined as situated performances of
interactions between strangers arising out of bod-
ily encounters in urban space. Following Sarah
Ahmed’s claim that ‘encounters between embod-
ied others hence involve spatial negotiations with
those who are already recognized as either familiar
or strange’ (Ahmed 2000, p. 24), with the idea of sit-
uational spaces we aim to contribute to the elaborate
debate in current geographies of urban encoun-
ter (e.g. laurier and philo 2006a, 2006b; valentine
2008; clayton 2009; Wessel 2009; dirksmeier and
Helbrecht 2010; Hemming 2011; Matejskova and
leitner 2011; Wilson 2011; Andersson et al. 2012;
leitner 2012; valentine and Waite 2012; valentine
2013; valentine and Sadgrove 2014), thereby re-
lecting on the role of culture and super-diversity
(vertovec 2007) in world society (Burton 1972;
luhmann 1990; Meyer et al. 1997).
the communicative conditions of world soci-
ety foster interactions between strangers and, conse-
quently, facilitate relections on interactions between
strangers as mundane instances of cultural emer-
gence. Here we use the term emergence in its clas-
sic sense as ‘a cumulative change, a change in which
certain characteristics supervene upon other charac-
teristics, these characteristics being adequate to ex-
plain the occurrence on their level’ (pepper 1926, p.
241). our main thesis, outlined in detail in the fol-
lowing sections, contends that interactions between
strangers in cities are rituals (Goffman 1967; collins
2004) involving bodily practices and performances
in urban space which shape cultures of encounter
in cities. the aim of this conceptualization is two-
fold. First, it enables us to think of encounters be-
tween strangers as a hinge between an individual’s
behaviour, cultural norms, and social commerce –
which, of course, includes questions of power. this