Development and Characterization of Ultrafiltration TiO
2
Magné li
Phase Reactive Electrochemical Membranes
Lun Guo, Yin Jing, and Brian P. Chaplin*
Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Illinois at Chicago, 810 S. Clinton Street, Chicago, Illinois 60607
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: This research focused on the synthesis, charac-
terization, and performance testing of a novel Magné li phase
(Ti
n
O
2n-1
), n = 4 to 6, reactive electrochemical membrane
(REM) for water treatment. The REMs were synthesized from
tubular asymmetric TiO
2
ultrafiltration membranes, and
optimal reactivity was achieved for REMs composed of high
purity Ti
4
O
7
. Probe molecules were used to assess outer-sphere
charge transfer (Fe(CN)
6
4-
) and organic compound oxidation
through both direct oxidation (oxalic acid) and formation of
OH
•
(coumarin, terephthalic acid). High membrane fluxes
(3208 L m
-2
h
-1
bar
-1
(LMH bar
-1
)) were achieved and
resulted in a convection-enhanced rate constant for Fe(CN)
6
4-
oxidation of 1.4 × 10
-4
ms
-1
, which is the highest reported in
an electrochemical flow-through reactor and approached the kinetic limit. The optimal removal rate for oxalic acid was 401.5 ±
18.1 mmol h
-1
m
-2
at 793 LMH, with approximately 84% current efficiency. Experiments indicate OH
•
were produced only on
the Ti
4
O
7
REM and not on less reduced phases (e.g., Ti
6
O
11
). REMs were also tested for oxyanion separation. Approximately
67% removal of a 1 mM NO
3
-
solution was achieved at 58 LMH, with energy consumption of 0.22 kWh m
-3
. These results
demonstrate the extreme promise of REMs for water treatment applications.
■
INTRODUCTION
Reactive electrochemical membranes (REMs) are a promising
technology that combine an electrochemical advanced
oxidation process (EAOP) and physical separation into a
single water treatment device. EAOP is the process by which
water is oxidized on an anode surface to form hydroxyl radicals
(OH
•
), which react with a wide range of recalcitrant organic
and inorganic compounds often at diffusion-controlled rates.
1
Magne ́ li phase titanium oxides (Ti
n
O
2n-1
), n = 4 to 10, have
been utilized for REM fabrication because they can be
synthesized into porous monolithic structures at low cost and
are reported to produce OH
•
via water oxidation.
2,3
The unique
chemical, electrical, and magnetic properties of Ti
n
O
2n-1
have
motivated their use as battery electrodes,
4-6
fuel cell
supports,
6,7
memristor devices,
8,9
photocatalysts,
10
and electro-
des for electrochemical oxidation,
11,12
and reduction
6,13,14
of
water contaminants.
The work by Zaky and Chaplin demonstrated that
commercial, tubular Ti
n
O
2n-1
monolithic electrodes (Ebonex)
could be utilized as REMs for the oxidation of several organic
compounds at high current efficiencies.
3
Results showed that
reaction rates were limited by convection to the REM, due to
the fast radial diffusion of compounds in the micron-sized REM
pores.
3
These promising results suggest that reaction rates can
be increased by simply increasing the permeate flux and that
intrinsic reaction rates of the electrode should be obtained at
sufficiently high fluxes. However, the Ebonex REM pore
structure was not tailored for water treatment, which resulted in
a high-pressure drop across the membrane and thus low
pressure-normalized permeate fluxes (e.g., 50-70 L m
-2
h
-1
bar
-1
(LMH bar
-1
)).
2,3
Additionally, Ebonex electrodes often
contain a range of Magné li phases (n = 4 to 10),
15
which can
affect electrode conductivity and presumably EAOP perform-
ance. While it is well-known that Ti
4
O
7
is the most conductive
Magne ́ li phase suboxide (e.g., 20 000-100 000 S m
-1
),
6,15
studies focused on providing a link between Magne ́ li phase
composition and EAOP performance are lacking.
Another unexplored area of research for REMs is their use as
electrostatic barriers for ion separation. Related technologies,
such as carbon nanotube-polymer composite membranes,
16,17
have shown the ability to reduce membrane fouling due to
electrostatic repulsion of negatively charged organics at
cathodically polarized membrane surfaces. However, to our
knowledge, work focused on ion separation by an electrically
conductive membrane has not been reported. Although
electrodialysis (ED) is similar in function, the technology is
fundamentally different from REMs. ED membranes possess
high ionic conductivity but are electrically insulating. Polymeric
ED membranes suffer from high production costs, are
Received: September 8, 2015
Revised: December 25, 2015
Accepted: January 5, 2016
Article
pubs.acs.org/est
© XXXX American Chemical Society A DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.5b04366
Environ. Sci. Technol. XXXX, XXX, XXX-XXX