Soft X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy and Imaging of Sulfur in Lapis Lazuli
Marc S. Walton
1
, Alessa A. Gambardella
2
, and Catherine M. Schmidt Patterson
2
1
Northwestern University/Art Institute of Chicago Center for Scientific Studies in the Arts
(NU-ACCESS), Evanston, IL, USA.
2
Getty Conservation Institute, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Since antiquity, lapis lazuli has been highly valued across many cultures for its bright blue color. Due to
the material’s significance, there has long been interest in understanding its color variations and
determining its geographic origin, whether used as the processed pigment ultramarine in painted works
of art (e.g. paintings and manuscripts) or the raw lapis lazuli stone in cultural heritage objects (e.g.
jewelry and inlaid decorations). While the most well-known source of lapis lazuli is Afghanistan, there
are several other sources, including sites in Tajikistan, Iran, Russia, Canada, and Chile. Naturally
occurring lapis lazuli contains the blue mineral lazurite (Na
6
Ca
2
(Al
6
Si6O
24
)(SO
4
,S
3
,S
2
,Cl,OH)
2
) with a
variety of accessory minerals that are common to many of the known geological deposits—e.g. hauyne
(Na
3
Ca(Si
3
Al
3
)O
12
(SO
4
)), pyrite (FeS
2
), calcium carbonate (CaCO
3
), and diopside (MgCaSi
2
O
6
). Much
of the current research on the provenance of lapis lazuli has focused on the spectroscopic characteristics,
the composition, and the overall distribution of the accessory minerals within the whole rock [1-4]. For
example, work in our laboratory has shown that diopside inclusions in lapis lazuli sometimes have a
fluorescent response to infrared wavelengths which may be characteristic of the geological deposit [5].
One challenge with basing provenance on the composition and distribution of accessory minerals is that
the accessory minerals are mostly removed during the production of the ultramarine pigment, a process
that requires crushing, sorting, and soaking the rock in an alkaline solution. Thus, a technique that
focuses on in-situ analysis of the lazurite mineral alone, which remains chemically unaltered during this
intensive processing, is desirable. Expanding on our previous work, this study therefore focuses on the
lazurite component of lapis lazuli.
Lazurite is a member of the sodalite group that is defined by its alumino-silicate cage structure.
According to literature, the characteristic blue color of the lazurite is due to the presence of polysulfide
anions trapped within the cage at the time of the rock formation via contact metamorphism.
Furthermore, the overall intensity of the blue color is thought to be due to both the total amount of
polysulfide and how this polysulfide anion is coupled to the surrounding molecular framework [2]. Here
we investigate the sulfur speciation within the aluminosilicate cage of lazurite—using a diverse sample
set of both lapis lazuli and ultramarine pigments from many origins including Afghanistan, Russia, and
Chile—as a potential means for identifying a geological fingerprint.
Sulfur x-ray absorption near edge structure (XANES) spectroscopy was performed on the samples using
the newly developed soft X-ray Beamline (14-3) at the Stanford Synchrotron Radiation Lightsource
(SSRL). S K-edge XANES has previously been used to study the origins of color in lazurite [6]. As is
shown in Figure 1, the S K-edge spectrum collected on a sample originating in Afghanistan and
Tajikistan (blue and green traces respectively). All of the spectra share a strong peak at 2483 eV that
may be assigned to sulfate (SO
2
4-
) in the lazurite structure. However, at lower energies notable
differences in each spectrum may be observed in the position and shape of the pre-edge peaks. The
pre-edge features are of particular interest to this study since they are associated with thiosulfate (S
2
O
3
2-
)
species centered around ~2473 eV and the polysulfide (S
x
2-
) at ~2469 eV [6]. These data allow sulfate,
2040
doi:10.1017/S1431927614011933
Microsc. Microanal. 20 (Suppl 3), 2014
© Microscopy Society of America 2014