Prioritising and Linking Business and IT Goals in the Financial Sector
Wim Van Grembergen, Ph.D. Steven De Haes Hilde Van Brempt
University of Antwerp University of Antwerp University of Antwerp
Wim.VanGrembergen@ua.ac.be Management School Management School
Steven.DeHaes@ua.ac.be Hilde.VanBrempt@ua.ac.be
Abstract
IT governance and strategic alignment are issues that
are high on the agenda in many organisations. To
address those challenges, it is important that an
organisation has a good view on its business goals and
how IT goals and IT processes support the
achievement of those goals. This research is aimed at
providing guidance in building up such a cascade of
business goals, IT goals and IT processes. This
research builds on the list of business goals and IT
goals, provided in COBIT4.0, and further validates
and elaborates this material leveraging the Delphi
research method.
1. Introduction
Today, IT is more critical to the business than ever
(ITGI [7]), moving away from a cost-only factor to a
service that is actually contributing in the achievement
of the business objectives. Aligning IT to the business,
also known as strategic alignment remains one of the
major challenges of IT management and business
management in general. In IT related literature,
amongst the different alignment definitions, a well-
perceived view on strategic alignment is “the degree to
which the information technology mission, objectives
and plans support and are supported by the business
mission, objectives and plans” (Chan [3]). In the same
article, Chan defines strategic alignment as the fit
between the priorities and activities of the IT function
and those of the business unit. Numerous articles have
been written on strategic alignment and according to
different research in this area, there’s still a lot of work
ahead for improving the strategic fit between IT and
business (Chan [3], Luftman [9], Reich [11]).
To address the alignment challenges, it is important
for an organisation to have a clear and in-depth view
regarding its business goals and how IT goals and IT
processes support those goals. Each organization
should own clear business goals and a related business
strategy, communicated to and adopted by the entire
organization. In earlier research on aligning IT and
business goals (Van Grembergen et al. [14], Benson
[2]) it was confirmed that in practice this is not always
the case. Business strategy and goals are not always
formally written out and if so, it is not always the case
that people throughout the organization are aware of it.
Preferably, IT management is involved early in the
business strategy definition process, especially in those
companies that highly rely on IT, as also promoted by
the IT governance framework COBIT 4.0 (Control
Objectives for Information and Related Technologies),
which states in its control objectives on business – IT
alignment: “…Make sure the business direction to
which IT is aligned is understood. The business and IT
strategies should be integrated, clearly linking
enterprise goals and IT goals and recognising
opportunities as well as current capability limitations,
and broadly communicated. Identify where the
business (strategy) is critically dependent on IT and
mediate between imperatives of the business and the
technology, so agreed priorities can be established.”
(ITGI [6])
2. Research scope
The focus of this research is on understanding the
relationship between business goals, IT goals and IT
processes, as illustrated in Figure 1. In achieving
strategic alignment, it is important to clearly
understand business and IT goals and to identify
priorities and relationships. The defined IT goals in
turn can be translated into more detailed IT processes,
supporting IT goals and by extent business goals. A
scan through literature learns that, although this subject
is practical relevant, not a lot of research has been
executed in this domain. It is therefore clear that a
more thorough research of this cascade is needed.
In order to gain a better understanding of the
cascade of business goals, IT goals and IT processes, a
pilot study (Van Grembergen et al. [14]) was
conducted where eight industries were analysed. In-
Proceedings of the 40th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences - 2007
1 © 1530-1605/07 $20.00 2007 IEEE
Proceedings of the 40th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS'07)
0-7695-2755-8/07 $20.00 © 2007