Numerical Methods in Geotechnical Engineering – Hicks, Brinkgreve & Rohe (Eds)
© 2014Taylor & Francis Group, London, 978-1-138-00146-6
A preliminary study of rheological models for run-out distance
modelling of sensitive clay debris
V. Thakur
Norwegian Public Roads Administration, Norway
Aalesund University College, Norway
D. Nigussie & S.A. Degago
Norwegian Public Roads Administration, Norway
ABSTRACT: Estimating the extent of post-failure movements is vital in the context of hazard mapping,
preparedness and mitigation strategies. The current practice is limited to simplified empirical approaches which
are mainly attributed to poor understanding of the mechanisms associated with the post-failure movements of
sensitive clay debris. In this work, a 3D numerical tool mainly used for the dynamic analysis of rapid landslides
and rock avalanches (DAN) has been adopted to make a preliminary study on run-out modelling of sensitive
clay debris. In doing so, a recent case of a flow slide in Norway is used as a reference to evaluate numerical
predictions. Results are discussed in light of the field data for a sensitive clay flow slide.
1 BACKGROUND
Flow slide in sensitive clays deposits of Scandinavia
is a well-known geo-hazard. Consequently, the ret-
rogression and the run-out of sensitive clay debris
pose a serious risk to human lives, infrastructure, and
sensitive ecosystems within their range (Figure 1).
Therefore, accurate prediction of flow slide behaviour,
including retrogression distance, run-out length and
flow velocity, is essential for hazard risk assessment.
Although the estimation of landslide retrogression
in sensitive clays has received considerable attention,
an appropriate numerical method for investigating the
run-out of sensitive clay debris remains a topic of
research.
2 INTRODUCTION
Various literature, e.g. Mitchell and Markell (1974);
Corominas (1996); Rickenmann (1999); Fell et al.
Figure 1. Run-out of sensitive clay debris (Thakur and
Degago, 2014).
(2000); Fannin & Wise (2001); Legros (2002);
Vaunat & Leroueil (2002); Bathurst et al. (2003);
Crosta et al. (2003); Hungr 2005; Locat & Lee
(2005); L’Heureux (2012); Thakur & Degago (2013)
proposes various analytical and empirical relations to
estimate the retrogression and the run-out distances.
Thakur et al. (2014) present a comprehensive sum-
mary of various approaches adopted for the estimation
of run-out distances based on geometrical aspects
and individual soil parameters such as; remoulded
shear strength, liquidity index, quickness, soil sen-
sitivity. They emphasised on the limited success of
the empirical correlations derived from an individ-
ual parameter and advocated on use of integrated
approaches that take into account a wide range of
geotechnical parameters.
Numerical modelling of run-out distance of sen-
sitive clay debris has so far received a very little
focus. Different approaches and methods have been
developed in the past for a quantitative risk analysis
using dynamic run-out models for debris flows and
avalanches. Some of the commonly used models to
estimate run-out distances are quasi-two-dimensional
numerical models (e.g., BING (Imran et al. 2001) and
NIS (Norem et al. 1987)) and quasi-three-dimensional
models (e.g., DAN3D (Hungr 1995; McDougall &
Hungr, 2004), MassMov2D (Beguería et al. 2009),
LS-RAIPD (Sassa 1988) and RAMMS (Christen et al.
2002). However, none of these tools are specifically
developed for the estimation of the run-out distance of
sensitive clay debris. This can be perhaps attributed to,
among other factors, an insufficient knowledge about
the complex rheological behaviour of sensitive clays
115