A Variable Structure Multiple Model Particle
Filter for GMTI Tracking
M. Sanjeev Arulampalam
DSTO, Adelaide, Australia.
sanjeev.arulampalam@dsto.defence.gov.au
Matthew Orton
Cambridge University, U.K
mro20@eng.cam.ac.uk
Neil Gordon
Qinetiq, Malvern, U.K.
njgordon@taz.qinetiq.com
Branko Ristic
DSTO, Adelaide, Australia
branko.ristic@dsto.defence.gov.au
Abstract – The problem of tracking ground targets
with GMTI sensors has received some attention in the
recent past. In addition to standard GMTI sensor mea-
surements, one is interested in using non-standard in-
formation such as road maps, and terrain-related visi-
bility conditions to enhance tracker performance. The
conventional approach to this problem has been to use
the Variable structure IMM (VS-IMM), which uses the
concept of directional process noise to model motion
along particular roads. In this paper, we present a par-
ticle filter based approach to this problem which we call
Variable structure Multiple model Particle filter (VS-
MMPF). Simulation results show that the performance
of the VS-MMPF is much superior to that of VS-IMM.
Keywords: GMTI Tracking, Variable Structure
IMM, Particle Filter.
1 Introduction
In standard tracking problems, the only inputs avail-
able to the tracker are sensor measurements obtained
through one or more sensors. However, in some ap-
plications there may be some additional information
available which could be exploited in the estimation
process. For instance, one may have some knowledge
of the environment in which the target is being tracked
or there may be some knowledge of some constraints on
the dynamic motion of the target, such as speed con-
straints. An example application in a military context
is Ground Moving Target Indicator (GMTI) tracking,
where one may have some information of the terrain,
such as road maps and visibility conditions. The ques-
tion is, can this information be used by the tracker to
produce better estimates of the target state?
It turns out that incorporating such non-standard
information in conventional Kalman filter based track-
ers is not an easy task. The reason is that, in gen-
eral, incorporating non-standard information leads to
highly non-Gaussian posterior densities, and conven-
tional trackers cannot easily handle propagation of
non-Gaussian densities in a dynamic state estimation
framework. However, there has been some attempt at
incorporating such non-standard information within a
Kalman filter based tracker. The most common of
these is the Variable Structure Interacting Multiple
Model (VS-IMM) algorithm [4].
The VS-IMM uses a modified version of the standard
IMM, where the number, and structure, of the multi-
ple models active at any particular time are allowed to
vary. The various models may represent motion un-
der different conditions of visibility, road constraints
and target speeds. Although the VS-IMM has been
shown to produce better results than methods that
don’t use such non-standard information, it still has
major drawbacks. In particular, the non-standard in-
formation available to the tracker will lead to highly
non-Gaussian posterior pdfs which are approximated
by a finite mixture of Gaussians. In addition, the VS-
IMM does not have a mechanism to incorporate hard
constraints on position and speed. Because of these
weaknesses, the use of VS-IMM has only resulted in
modest improvement in accuracy over methods that
do not use such non-standard information.
In this project we propose a new algorithm based
on Sequential Monte Carlo methods, which we term
Variable Structure Multiple Model Particle Filter (VS-
MMPF). The basic principle is to use particles (ran-
dom samples) to represent the posterior density of the
state of a target in a dynamic state estimation frame-
work where non-standard information is utilised. Since
particle filtering methods have no restrictions on the
type of models, including the noise distributions used,
927 ISIF © 2002