Multilevel bidimensional empirical mode decomposition: a
new speckle reduction method in digital holography
Marco Leo,
a,
* Roberta Piccolo,
a
Cosimo Distante,
a
Pasquale Memmolo,
b
Melania Paturzo,
b
and Pietro Ferraro
b
a
National Institute of Optics–CNR, via della Libertà 3, Arnesano LE 73014, Italy
b
National Institute of Optics–CNR via Campi Flegrei 34, Pozzuoli NA 80078, Italy
Abstract. The paper presents a new automatic technique for speckle reduction in the context of digital holog-
raphy. Speckle noise is a superposition of unwanted spots over objects of interest, due to the behavior of a
coherence source of radiation with the object surface characteristics. In the proposed denoising method, bidi-
mensional empirical mode decomposition is used to decompose the image signal, which is then filtered through
the Frost filter. The proposed technique was preliminarily tested on the “Lena” image for quality assessment in
terms of peak signal-to-noise ratio. Then, its denoising capability was assessed on different holographic images
on which also the comparison (using both blind metrics and visual inspection) with the leading strategies in the
state of the art was favorably performed. © 2014 Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers (SPIE) [DOI: 10.1117/1.OE.53.11
.XXXXXX]
Keywords: digital holography; bidimensional empirical mode decomposition; speckle reduction; image denoising; Frost filter.
Paper 140257SSP received Feb. 14, 2014; revised manuscript received May 23, 2014; accepted for publication May 28, 2014.
1 Introduction
In 1971, the Hungarian–British physicist Dennis Gabor was
awarded with the Nobel Prize in Physics for the invention
and development of the holographic method.
1
This method
is a means for recording and reconstructing the whole
information contained in an optical wavefront, namely
amplitude and phase, and not just intensity as in photogra-
phy: this allows a three-dimensional (3-D) reconstruction of
the object. In digital holography (DH),
2
a charge coupled
device (CCD) camera is used to record the holograms.
Unfortunately, these reconstructed structures are corrupted
by speckle noise. A speckle pattern results when an object
is illuminated by a coherent source of radiation and the
object has a surface structure that is roughly of the order
of a wavelength of the incident radiation. In the image
plane, the presence of speckle is evident as a collection of
spots superimposed upon the actual object.
Speckle noise makes image quality lower and its removal
is challenging since, often, the removing process destroys
important structures in the image that are in the same
scale of a speckle pattern.
Several speckle-removing approaches have been pro-
posed in the last decades and they can be divided into
two main categories: image-processing techniques
3
and
optical techniques.
4
Optical techniques are based on the def-
inition of specific acquisition setup. Instead, digital image-
processing techniques do not affect the acquisition setup but
they try to reduce the noise by numerical processing of the
recorded data.
Nonadaptive filters (e.g., mean or median filters
3
) have
been largely used for this purpose. To reduce the impact
of filtering in image areas containing texture and edges,
adaptive filters have also been introduced [e.g., Frost filter,
5
Lee filter,
6
discrete Fourier filtering,
7
nonlocal means filter-
ing (NLM)
8
]. To reduce noise, empirical mode
decomposition method (EMD) and bidimensional empirical
mode decomposition (BEMD) method were also pro-
posed.
9–11
In this paper, a multiresolution technique is introduced to
analyze the input signal at different scales: it makes use of an
automatic reconstruction process that, on the basis of image
quality indicators, is able to evaluate which portion of fre-
quency bands (in the multiresolution framework) can be
suppressed to the aim of reducing the speckle and to preserve
the image contents.
The proposed multiresolution framework is based on the
BEMD procedure and, in particular, it exploits a recently
introduced, modified version of the classical BEMD that
allows multilevel decomposition.
12,13
The key idea is to ana-
lyze the reconstructed digital holograms by using the afore-
said multilevel BEMD and then to perform an automatic sub-
band decimation stage guided by speckle index indicators.
This introduces a twofold level of innovation with respect
to state-of-the-art techniques: on the one side, BEMD is
first time used for denoising reconstructed holograms (it
was only already used in DH for fringe pattern denois-
ing
14–17
). On the other side, it introduces a multilevel strategy
which is able to automatically select the speckle noise sub-
band, making it suitable to be easily exploited when different
acquisition setups are used.
2 Bidimensional Empirical Mode Decomposition
BEMD is a two-dimensional (2-D) extension of the classical
EMD. In general, EMD
18
is a fully data-driven method used
to remove the noise produced in transform process without
making any assumptions on the initial data. Since it provides
more advantages when processing complex signals, EMD
has been used in a wide range of fields, including biology,
19
geophysics,
20
radar,
21
and medicine.
22
*Address all correspondence to: Marco Leo, E-mail: marco.leo@ino.it 0091-3286/2014/$25.00 © 2014 SPIE
Optical Engineering XXXXXX-1 November 2014 • Vol. 53(11)
Optical Engineering 53(11), XXXXXX (November 2014)