Electron contribution to photon transport in
coupled photon-electron problems: inner-shell
impact ionization correction to XRF
Jorge E. Fernandez,
a
* Viviana Scot,
a
Luca Verardi
b
and Francesc Salvat
c
The Monte Carlo code PENELOPE (coupled electron-photon Monte Carlo) has been used to compute the effect of the
secondary electrons on the X-ray fluorescence characteristic lines. The mechanism that produces this contribution is the
inner-shell impact ionization. The ad hoc code KERNEL (which calls the PENELOPE library) has been used to simulate a forced
first collision at the origin of coordinates. The electron correction (produced by the secondary electrons and their multiple
scattering) has been studied in terms of angle, space and energy. The energy dependence has been quantified in the interval
1–150 keV, for all the emission lines (K, L and M) of the elements with atomic numbers Z = 11–92. For each characteristic line,
the energy dependence is described by simple parametric expressions corresponding to the five energy regions delimited by
the K, L1, L2 and L3 absorption edges. It has been introduced a new photon kernel comprising the correction due to inner-shell
impact ionization. The new kernel is suitable to be adopted in photon transport codes (either deterministic or Monte Carlo)
with a minimal effort. Finally, the new kernel has been studied for different elements and lines to trace a general behavior.
Copyright © 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Introduction
The most accurate description of the radiation field in X-ray spec-
trometry requires the modeling of coupled photon-electron
transport, because Compton scattering and photoelectric effect
give both photons and electrons as secondary particles. The
solution for the coupled problem is time consuming because
the electrons interact continuously with the medium and there-
fore, the number of electron collisions is always very high. For this
reason, transport codes usually neglect the electron contribu-
tions shown in Fig. 1, and consequently, only photon transport
is considered. Nevertheless, secondary electrons contribute to
the photon field through electron-photon conversion mecha-
nisms like bremsstrahlung (which produces a continuous photon
spectrum) and inner-shell impact ionization (ISII) (which modifies
the intensity of the characteristic lines) (Fig. 2). Other processes,
not mentioned here, that contribute to the multiple scattering
of electrons (Auger electrons, Coster-Kronig transitions, etc.)
need to be also considered. In what follows, we will focus on ISII,
which is the only effect that modifies the intensity of the charac-
teristic lines, and therefore, it is of interest in X-ray fluorescence
(XRF) analysis.
Several authors have tried to describe the XRF due to secondary
electrons by focusing separately on the contributions from K-
photoelectrons,
[1]
Auger electrons,
[2]
both effects,
[3]
and Compton
electrons.
[4]
The whole problem is very complex because all of
these mechanisms (plus other not mentioned) have to be consid-
ered together, and the fact that electrons interact continuously
and locally (compared with the photons) makes it necessary to
describe carefully the multiple scattering of the electrons. A prac-
tical approach to study the mentioned mechanisms in presence of
multiple scattering is to recur to a coupled photon-electron
Monte Carlo (MC) code. Some authors
[5,6]
have developed ad
hoc MC codes on the basis of simplified models of electron
transport to evaluate the effect of secondary electrons in thin
layers. To understand the extent of the electron contributions
on multilayers,
[5,7,8]
some experiments have been performed
using the polychromatic excitation of X-ray tubes, showing that
the effect exists, but it is lower than expected. Kawahara et al.
[8]
described also an experiment with tunable monochromatic
excitation at BESSY II. In this case, it appeared a very strong
discontinuity of the Cr–L line intensity in correspondence with
the Cr–K edge, which is due to the cascade effect. The apparent
contradiction of these experiments needs to be explained by
recourse to an MC code using a detailed description of the multi-
ple scattering of electrons. In this work, it has been used the MC
code PENELOPE
[9]
(coupled electron-photon MC) to compute
the effect of the secondary electrons into the photon transport.
In particular, PENELOPE has been used to compute a corrective
term to the photon kernel, which fully describes the effect of ISII
on the characteristic line emission. It is given a formal expression
of a new photon kernel comprising the correction for ISII. The new
kernel is suitable to be adopted in photon transport codes (either
deterministic or MC) with a minimal increase in complexity.
* Correspondence to: Jorge E. Fernandez, Laboratory of Montecuccolino-
Department of Industrial Engineering (DIN), Alma Mater Studiorum University
of Bologna, via dei Colli, 16, I-40136, Bologna, Italy. E-mail: jorge.
fernandez@unibo.it
a Laboratory of Montecuccolino (DIN), Alma Mater Studiorum University of
Bologna, via dei Colli, 16, 40136 Bologna, Italy
b Department of Electrical, Electronic and Information Engineering “Guglielmo
Marconi” (DEI), Alma Mater Studiorum University of Bologna, Viale del Risorgi-
mento 2, 40136 Bologna, Italy
c Facultat de Física (ECM), Universitat de Barcelona, Diagonal 647, 08028
Barcelona, Spain
X-Ray Spectrom. 2013, 42, 189–196 Copyright © 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Research article
Accepted: 21 December 2012 Published online in Wiley Online Library: 22 May 2013
(wileyonlinelibrary.com) DOI 10.1002/xrs.2473
189