BENDING LIMIT PREDICTION OF
AN ALUMINUM THIN SHEET
S. Thuillier
*
, N. Le Maoût, P.Y. Manach
LIMATB, Université de Bretagne-Sud, Université européenne de Bretagne
ABSTRACT: The aim of this work is to predict the occurrence of rupture during bending of an aluminum alloy thin
sheet by considering ductile damage. The first step consists in characterizing the mechanical behaviour of the material
under different strain paths, such as tension of straight and notched samples and equibiaxial tension, up to necking and
final rupture. The parameters of Gurson-Tvergaard-Needleman model are then identified for different triaxiality ratios
ranging from 0.3 up to 0.67. Inverse identification is performed, by coupling the optimization software with a finite
element code. A value of 0.15 for the critical void volume fraction corresponding to the void coalescence is obtained. In
order to determine experimentally the onset of rupture in bending for this material, square specimen of length 60 mm
are bent over a small radius of 0.2 mm, with a designed-on-purpose device. The area just beneath the bending tool is
observed with a scanning electron microscope, for different tool displacements. The bending test is then simulated and a
good correlation between the numerical onset of rupture, defined when the void volume fraction equals its critical value,
and the occurrence of cracks on the sample surface is found.
KEYWORDS: Mechanical behavior, Ductile damage, Aluminum alloy, Forming process
1 INTRODUCTION
Numerical validation of the parameters of a drawing or
assembly process, such as hemming, necessitates the
taking into account of the material limits, such as
necking and rupture. This is usually performed by using
forming limit curves. However, in the case of flanging
and hemming processes, using these curves is no longer
possible due to the bending over a small radius [1].
Figure 1: Aspect of the bent area during hemming.
Figure 1 shows the bent area, which can exhibit either a
weak peel orange aspect (acceptable in the automotive
industry), or fine and localized cracks hardly to be seen
with bare eyes (just acceptable) or a complete failure
(non-acceptable) [2]. To predict these different states, it
was assumed to relate them with the void volume
fraction of a ductile damage model of Gurson's type [3].
This method, whatever the damage model, has already
been described in the literature [4-6]. Tensile tests on
both straight and notched samples and equibiaxial tests
have been performed, to identify material parameters [1].
In this paper, a dedicated bending test for square samples
have been designed, to reproduce a bending similar to
the one occuring during hemming. SEM observations of
the bent area as well as numerical simulation of the test
are performed, in order to correlate the aspect of the bent
area with the critical void volume fraction.
2 MATERIAL
AA 6016 aluminium alloy thin sheet of thickness 1 mm
is used in this study. Its mechanical behavior has been
investigated with tensile tests on both straight and
notched samples and with equibiaxial tests, up to rupture
(see Figure 2). Gurson-Tveergard-Needleman (GTN) [3]
model is used and material parameters have been
optimized by inverse identification. As the tests are non-
homogeneous, either since the very begining or after
necking, the finite element code Abaqus is linked to the
optimization software SiDoLo [1]. Hill's 1948 yield
criterion has also been used but, as in this work only
tests in the rolling direction are taken into account, an
isotropic yield criterion is considered. Aluminum alloys
are very sensitive to ageing and tests were performed at
different maturation times (30 days and more than 6
months). This phenomenon is accounted for by
modifying the hardening curve, as shown in Figure 3.
Hardening is fitted with Voce-type equation, see
____________________
* Corresponding author: Université de Bretagne-Sud, centre de recherche C. Huyghens, LIMATB, rue de Saint Maudé, BP 92116, F-
56321 Lorient Cedex, sandrine.thuillier@univ-ubs.fr
DOI 10.1007/s12289-010-0747-
© Springer-Verlag France 2010
7
Int J Mater Form (2010) Vol. 3 Suppl 1:223 226 –