Neurosurgery in Papua New Guinea
Jeffrey V Rosenfeld MBBS FRACS FRCS(Ed) MS(Melb)*
David A K W a t t e r s ChM FRCS(Ed) t
Department of Neurosurgery*, The Melbourne Neuroscience Centre, Royal Melbourne Hospital. Department of Surgery t,
University of Papua New Guinea
Journal of Clinical Neuroscience 1995, 2 (2) :118-120 © Pearson Professional (Australia) Pty Ltd
Keywords: Papua New Guinea, Developing country, Tropics, Neurosurgery, Health care resources, Postgraduate
training
T h e war torn or famine stricken u n d e r d e v e l o p e d
countries such as Somalia, Ethiopia and Rwanda clearly
have very basic health care needs. Primary and preventive
strategies should be the priority. However, in politically
stable developing countries such as Papua New Guinea
where food supplies are available and primary health care
services and infrastructure are developed, there is a need
for adequately resourced and staffed secondary and
tertiary health care facilities. The World Bank report
emphasises primary and preventive health care to the
exclusion of specialist services.1 It is a fallacy to argue that
these services are unaffordable luxuries. Many lives can
be saved and much crippling morbidity prevented by the
provision of surgicalservices. This no less applies to
neurosurgery. Unfortunately, this is not the intention or
priority of many of the governments of the developing
world, the World Bank or the World Health Organization.
Papua New Guinea (PNG) is a developing country of
4 000 000 people to which Australia contributes significant
aid. The medical and surgical diseases encountered are
similar in type and distribution to other developing
countries in the tropics. 2 However, as the Western lifestyle
is adopted, standards of living improve, rapid urban
development ensues and life expectancy increases, the
i n c i d e n c e of cancer, 3'4 diabetes, 5 h y p e r t e n s i o n , 6
cardiovascular and cerebrovascular disease, 7 urban
violence and road trauma, s will increase significantly,
and with these trends the need for neurosurgical services
will become overwhelming. There is no neurosurgeon
or computerised tomographic scanner (CT) in PNG.
This is clearly an unacceptable situation, when it is
recognised that the ratio of neurosurgeons per head of
population is one or more per 200 000 in many developed
countries.
W h a t needs to be d o n e - - b y w h o m ?
The c o m m o n neurosurgical problems encountered in
PNG are trauma to the head and spine, infections of the
CNS, particularly tuberculosis (TB) and cryptococcosis,
cerebral mass lesions, and congenital problems such as
h y d r o c e p h a l u s , sincipital e n c e p h a l o c e l e , spinal
dysraphism and tethered cord.
Over 2 two-week periods in 1992 and 1993, a visiting
n e u r o s u r g e o n (JVR) e n c o u n t e r e d 82 neurosurgical
patients. 55 (67.1%) were consultations, 23 (28%) had
elective surgery, 4 (4.8%) had emergency surgery and 16
(19.5%) cases were awaiting surgery. The cases consisted
of 9 major groupings: neurotrauma 18 (7 severe), spine
18, congenital 13, hydrocephalus 4, scalp, skull, orbit 6,
vascular 2, peripheral nerve 3, and neurology 5. Thus,
there is plenty of potential work for a neurosurgeon in
PNG.
The general surgeons are able to cope with many acute
neurosurgical problems provided they have received at
least some relevant training and experience which is
provided in the four year general surgical training
p r o g r a m m e (MMed). T h e m a n a g e m e n t of raised
intracranial pressure is difficult without the benefit of CT,
but it is still possible to adequately diagnose and treat these
patients in PNG and other developing countries. 9 At
present, clinical localisation of cerebral mass lesions
supplemented with ventriculography, encephalography or
cerebral angiography p e r f o r m e d with cut films and a
manual changer must suffice. However, these investiga-
tions are not usually performed because of the general
unavailability of craniotomy.
The successful management of head injury by general
surgeons has recently been reported from Malaysia 1° and
in Central Africa. 11 The isolated general surgeon may
repair selected ethmoidal encephaloceles transfacially and
avoid craniotomy. 19 The general surgeon may also be
technically competent to correct extradural spinal cord
c o m p r e s s i o n , spinal TB, h y d r o c e p h a l u s , myelo-
meningocele, or drain an intracranial epidural abscess
secondary to sinus infection, but will require extensive
experience and judgement to comprehensively manage
these more challenging problems.
118 J. Clin. Neuroscience Volume 2 Number 2 April 1995