ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Gender differences in presentation and outcome of
nonfunctioning pituitary macroadenomas
Carmela Caputo*, Tom Sutherland†, Stephen Farish‡, Peter McNeill§, Kong W. Ng* and Warrick J. Inder*¶**
*Department of Endocrinology, St Vincent’s Hospital, †Department of Radiology, St Vincent’s Hospital, ‡Melbourne Medical School,
University of Melbourne, §Department of Neurosurgery, St Vincent’s Hospital, Melbourne, Vic., ¶Department of Endocrinology,
Princess Alexandra Hospital, and **School of Medicine, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Qld, Australia
Summary
Objectives Few data exist regarding gender differences in hor-
monal outcomes in nonfunctioning pituitary macroadenomas
(NFPMA). The aim was to assess whether there are gender dif-
ferences in hormonal outcomes in NFPMA following pituitary
surgery at a single centre.
Design and methods Retrospective review of cases undergoing
a first surgical procedure for NFPMA. Preoperative hormonal
function was available for 122 cases at presentation and 94
cases 6 months postoperatively. Multiple hormone deficiency
was defined as 2 hormonal axis losses. Tumour size and
invasion on MRI scan were assessed independently by a single
neuroradiologist.
Results At presentation, men were more likely than women to
have multiple hormonal deficiency (47% vs 28%, P = 0038).
Premenopausal women tended to have smaller adenomas than
men, but neither adenoma size nor invasion was associated with
multiple hormonal deficiency at presentation. Postoperatively,
differences were observed with only 14% of premenopausal
women exhibiting multiple hormone deficiency, compared with
36% of postmenopausal women and 46% of men (P = 003).
Overall, postoperative hormonal recovery was observed in over
one-third of cases. Greatest recovery occurred in the gonadal
axis of 60% (6/10) premenopausal women compared with 19%
(8/43) of other groups combined (P = 0007).
Conclusions Premenopausal women with NFPMA appear to
have favourable hormonal outcomes. This may be due to a com-
plex interplay between smaller tumour size and shorter disease
duration. There should be no hesitation in offering pituitary sur-
gery to premenopausal women with NFPMA, who have the
most to gain in terms of restoration of hormonal function.
(Received 3 April 2012; returned for revision 8 July 2012; finally
revised 6 August 2012; accepted 6 August 2012)
Introduction
Pituitary adenomas are the commonest intracranial neoplasm, with
prevalence studies showing approximately one in 1000 individuals
having a clinically relevant pituitary adenoma.
1,2
In contrast, 10%
of the population may harbour small pituitary adenomas detect-
able on routine neuroimaging.
3
Recently, it has been shown that
incidence rates increase with age are higher in women early in life
but more common in men later in life.
4
Furthermore, men tend to
have larger tumours, possibly due to delayed diagnosis.
4,5
Pituitary adenomas may be associated with hormone defi-
ciency of varying degrees, with functioning tumours and mic-
roadenomas having fewer deficiencies than nonfunctioning
pituitary macroadenomas (NFPMA).
6–10
NFPMA have the high-
est rate of hormonal disturbances, but few data exist examining
gender differences. It has been observed that gonadal deficiency
is common in both men and women.
6,7,11–13
Deficiencies of
other pituitary hormones (thyroid and adrenal axes) are usually
reported with genders combined and include cases of pituitary
apoplexy. It is thus unclear whether there are specific gender dif-
ferences in hormonal status at presentation and postoperatively
in patients with NFPMA.
The aim of this study was to determine whether such gender
differences exist in hormonal function, both at presentation and
postoperatively among subjects with NFPMA via a retrospective
chart review. In addition, relationships between age at presenta-
tion, adenoma size and invasiveness, and hormonal status both
pre- and postoperatively have been examined.
Patients and methods
Between August 1995 and October 2010, 141 consecutive cases of
NFPMA were identified who underwent their first pituitary sur-
gery at St Vincent’s Hospital, Melbourne, Australia. One case had
a craniotomy, but the remainder were operated via the trans-
sphenoidal route. Surgery was undertaken by principal surgeon
PM in 77% cases, and the remainder by four other surgeons.
Sixteen cases presented with pituitary apoplexy and were
excluded from hormonal analysis. Preoperative hormonal data
were available at presentation for 122 cases, at 6 months for 94
cases, and for paired pre- and postoperative hormones for 93
Correspondence: Carmela Caputo, Department Endocrinology, 4th Floor
Daly Wing, St Vincent’s Hospital, 35 Victoria Parade, Fitzroy, Vic. 3065,
Australia. Tel.: +61 3 9288 3579; Fax: +613 9288 3590;
E-mail: carmela.caputo@svhm.org.au
564 © 2012 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Clinical Endocrinology (2013) 78, 564–570 doi: 10.1111/cen.12009