1 3
Exp Brain Res (2013) 228:437–443
DOI 10.1007/s00221-013-3575-4
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Brain mechanisms of valuable scientific problem finding inspired
by heuristic knowledge
Tong Dandan · Li Wenfu · Dai Tianen ·
Howard C. Nusbaum · Qiu Jiang · Zhang Qinglin
Received: 12 September 2012 / Accepted: 17 April 2013 / Published online: 29 May 2013
© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2013
related heuristic knowledge. The authors assumed that the
regions in the brain significantly activated by the finding
scientific problems with related heuristic knowledge condi-
tion compared with the finding normal problems without
related heuristic knowledge condition are relevant to the brain
mechanisms of scientific problem finding inspired by heuris-
tic knowledge. The first scenario more significantly activated
the left precuneus and left angular gyrus than did the second
scenario. These findings suggest that the precuneus is relevant
to the successful storage and retrieval of heuristic knowledge
and that the left angular gyrus is involved in the formation of
novel associations between heuristic knowledge and problem
situations for finding scientific problems.
Keywords Scientific problem finding · Heuristic
knowledge · Event-related fMRI · Precuneus ·
Angular gyrus
Introduction
Creativity is the foundation of human civilization and
depends on the human ability to break from existing think-
ing patterns and build something new (Dietrich and Kanso
2010). Throughout the history of human civilization, crea-
tive behavior appears to occur when inspired by some
heuristic knowledge in real-life scientific innovations. For
example, Newton obtained insights into the law of univer-
sal gravitation after observing a ripe apple drop from the
tree under which he was sitting.
Most previous studies investigated creativity through
insightful problem solving (Dietrich and Kanso 2010).
The development of creative problem solving has attracted
considerable research attention, especially the issue of
brain mechanisms that take place during creative problem
Abstract Heuristics through the application of heuristic
knowledge to the creation of imitation devices may be one
of the most common processes in scientific innovation. In
particular, heuristics suggests that innovation includes the
automatic activation of heuristic knowledge and formation of
novel associations between heuristic knowledge and problem
situations. In this study, 76 scientific innovation problem situ-
ations were selected as materials. Among these, 36 contain
related heuristic knowledge and 40 have no such information.
Through functional magnetic resonance imaging, the learn-
ing–testing paradigm was used to explore the brain mecha-
nisms of scientific problem finding inspired by heuristic
knowledge. Participants were asked to find a problem on the
basis of a given innovation problem situation. Two scenarios
were presented: finding scientific problems with related heu-
ristic knowledge and finding conventional problems without
Tong Dandan and Li Wenfu contributed equally to this work.
Li Wenfu is co-first author
T. Dandan · L. Wenfu · D. Tianen · Q. Jiang (*) ·
Z. Qinglin (*)
Key Laboratory of Cognition and Personality, Southwest
University, Ministry of Education, Chongqing 400715, China
e-mail: qiuj318@swu.edu.cn
Z. Qinglin
e-mail: zhangql@swu.edu.cn
T. Dandan
e-mail: tddtongdandan@163.com
T. Dandan · L. Wenfu · D. Tianen · Q. Jiang · Z. Qinglin
School of Psychology, Southwest University,
Chongqing 400715, China
H. C. Nusbaum
Department of Psychology, The University of Chicago,
Chicago, IL 60637, USA