Islam, and believes that only Islam can order a truly moral society. Such
fundamentalism has led to an ‘anti-Westernism’ that rejects the many
contributions Western thought has given to Islam and that Islam has
given to Western thought (p. 139). Sachedina believes such fundamen-
talism is a rejection of Muhammad’s pluralistic prophetic vision and
the true teaching of the Qur’an.
Sachedina’s theology combines religious freedom with a just moral
basis for governance. It provides ‘Muslims with a non-violent, inclu-
sively pluralistic framework’ that is ‘grounded in authoritative Islamic
texts’ (p. 161). Like Pannenberg, Sachedina emphasizes the importance
of the engagement of religion in public life. His work also has raised
some concerns. The most obvious is that Sachedina’s view is not
embraced by the majority of Muslims.
In the next two chapters Winkler has the theologies of Pannenberg
and Sachedina interact with one another. Winkler applies the two
theologians’ work to a discussion of the problems and possibilities of
‘honest and constructive’ inter-religious dialogue (p. 215). Pannen-
berg’s trinitarian understanding of God is invoked as a fruitful basis for
interfaith dialogue. Winkler and Pannenberg believe that religious dif-
ferences ‘are the loci for the most fruitful, interesting, and progressive
dialogues’ (p. 304).
Winkler concludes that these two theologians offer engaging propos-
als, but not final answers, for future dialogues. He sees inter-faith
dialogue as useful for moving to a richer understanding of God’s truth.
Dialogue does not require religions to relinquish their exclusive truth
claims but does require the parties to be respectful of the truths of
others. Winkler offers a perspective on how religious plurality can be
embraced and used to offset radicalism and conflict.
This book, originally Winkler’s doctoral thesis, is a fair assessment of
hopeful avenues for, and serious obstacles to, fruitful interfaith dia-
logue. All engaged with interfaith dialogues, or studying Christian and
Islamic responses to religious pluralism, religious globalization, and
future pathways of interfaith dialogue will find this book informative.
Armand J. Boehme
Trinity Lutheran Church, Faribault, MN
Food and Faith: A Theology of Eating, Norman Wirzba, Cambridge
University Press, 2011 (ISBN 978-0-521-14624-1), xix + 244 pp., pb
£16.99
Food and eating is burgeoning area of theological reflection, and
with the entrance of Wirzba’s work, one can well imagine the flow
Reviews 351
© 2013 Blackwell Publishing Ltd.