Ecological Modelling 146 (2001) 3 – 15
Northern bobwhite (Colinus irginianus ) abundance in
relation to yearly weather and long-term climate patterns
Jeffrey J. Lusk
a,
*, Fred S. Guthery
a
, Stephen J. DeMaso
b,1
a
Department of Forestry, 008 C Agriculture Hall, Oklahoma State Uniersity, Stillwater, OK 74078, USA
b
Oklahoma Department of Wildlife Conseration, Oklahoma City, OK 73105, USA
Abstract
We used a multilayered, backpropagation neural network to investigate the relative effects of yearly weather and
long-term climate patterns on the abundance of northern bobwhites (Colinus irginianus : hereafter, bobwhite) in
Oklahoma, USA. Bobwhite populations have been declining for several decades across the United States, and
predicted global climate change might accelerate the rate of decline. We were interested in whether bobwhite
abundance was more responsive to yearly precipitation and temperature, or to annual deviations from long-term
mean climate patterns. We used roadside count data collected over a 6 year period (1991–1997) by the Oklahoma
Department of Wildlife Conservation as a measure of bobwhite abundance. We standardized quail counts among
counties by calculating the standard normal deviate for each county. Weather data were obtained from weather
stations closest to the roadside-count route. We had 280 training cases and 68 test-validation cases. Two data sets
were constructed: one using yearly weather data (actual rainfall and temperature) and the second using annual
deviations from long-term mean values. We conducted simulation analyses to determine the nature of the relationship
between each dependent variable and the standardized bobwhite counts. A neural network with eight neurons was
most efficient for the yearly weather data, accounting for 25% of the variation in the training data. The adjusted
sum-of-squares for this model was 2.42. A four-neuron network was selected for the deviation-from-normal data set,
accounting for 23% of the variation in the training data. The adjusted sum-of-squares for the deviation model was
1.44, indicating it performed better than the model for yearly weather patterns. Deviation from long-term mean July
and August temperatures combined contributed 31.5% to the climate network’s predictions, and deviations from
mean winter, spring, and summer precipitation combined contributed 42.8% to the network’s predictions. As July
temperature increased over the long-term mean, the number of bobwhites counted increased over the route mean, but
the relationship decelerated at high July temperatures. Predicted increases in bobwhites counted were highest when
August temperatures were below the mean and decreased rapidly for all temperatures greater than the mean.
Predicted bobwhite counts increased asymptotically as winter rain increased over the long-term mean, but were
greatest at mean spring-rainfall amounts and at below average amounts of summer rainfall. We conclude that the
absolute changes in yearly weather pattern predicted by some global change models will not have as great an impact
on bobwhite abundance as will the magnitude of the deviations of these values from the climate bobwhites are
adapted to in this portion of their range. © 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
www.elsevier.com/locate/ecolmodel
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +1-405-7448047.
E-mail address: luskj@okstate.edu (J.J. Lusk).
1
Present address: Wildlife Division, Texas Parks and Wildlife Department, 4200 Smith School Road, Austin, TX 78744, USA.
0304-3800/01/$ - see front matter © 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
PII:S0304-3800(01)00292-7