InP surface properties under ICP plasma etching using mixtures of chlorides
and hydrides
B.Liu
1
, J-P.Landesman
1
, J-L.Leclercq
2
, A.Rhallabi
1
,M.Avella
3
, M.A. González
3
, J. Jiménez
3
, S. Guilet
2
,
C.Cardinaud
1
and F.Pommereau
4
1
IMN, UMR CNRS 6502, 2 Rue de la Houssinière, 44322 Nantes Cedex 3, France
2
LEOM, Ecole centrale de Lyon, UMR CNRS 5512, 36 Avenue Guy de Collongue, France
3
Física Materia Condensada, ETSII, 47011 Valladolid, Spain
4
Alcatel -Thales III-V Lab., Route de Nozay, F-91460 Marcoussis, France
Abstract
InP wafers after etching in an ICP (Inductively-Coupled Plasma) reactor with different kinds of reactant
gases have been carefully studied using surface sensitive techniques, in order to gain insight into the
mechanisms that control the process. Two types of reactive gas systems have been investigated, namely
Cl
2
/CH
4
/Ar mixtures on one side, and CH
4
/H
2
on the other. In both cases, the composition (flow rate) of the
different components was varied. X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS), Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM)
and micro-Raman were the techniques used. From the XPS data, information like the surface overall enrichment
(in P or In depending on the nature of the etching gases), quantitative surface stoichiometry, and detailed
chemical analysis could be derived. AFM images provided an estimate of the roughness increase, while micro-
Raman results were used to get indications on the surface structural disordering associated with the etching
process, as well as the changes induced in the electronic properties of the InP material (Surface Recombination
velocity – SRV – and modifications of the free carrier densities).
I. Introduction
Plasma etching techniques nowadays play a major role in
the fabrication process in the field of nano-technology,
especially for example when features with very high
surface/volume aspect ratio are necessary as is the case for
photonic crystal (PC) structures in InP. PCs based on InP
show an increasing number of applications as basic building
blocks for devices of interest in the area of optical
communications (waveguides with low optical losses, cavities
with high quality factor, laser diodes, photo-detectors…) (1,
2). Amongst these etching techniques, Inductively-Coupled
Plasma (ICP) etching is frequently used, in particular because
of the possibility to control separately the various important
process parameters in such a reactor (like the energy and
density of the ions reaching the surface) (3, 4). However, the
different aspects of the plasma/surface interaction mechanisms
taking place in such tools, especially for the case of InP, have
not been fully described yet. Several preliminary experimental
studies adressing this problem were published in the past, but
the results cannot be directly extended to processing
techniques like ICP. For example, Feurprier et al. (5) have
concluded that InP surfaces, during Reactive Ion Etching
(RIE) with CH
4
/H
2
, display a strong P-depletion. In an
experiment performed with Auger electron spectroscopy on
InP surfaces etched by Chemically Assisted Ion Beam Etching
(CAIBE), a technique somewhat different from standard dry
etching techniques like RIE or ICP, Youstey et al. (6)
observed an In depletion when Cl
2
was used as the chemically
active species (in conjunction with etching by Ar ions).
This approach to the problem of surface interactions taking
place during processing (etching) requires specific
experiments, where the whole area of the material is exposed
to the plasma simultaneously, meaning that no geometrical
structure (PC or other) defined by features transferred through
a mask layer should be included. This is due to the limited
spatial resolution of the characterisation techniques, in
particular X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS). The
drawback of this approach is of course that some phenomena
(like for example the dependence of the etching mechanisms –
etch rate, … - on the geometrical factors of the features to be
etched) cannot be included.
Nevetheless, the outputs of such an experimental approach
are essential for the general understanding and control of
etching techniques like ICP. In particular, many of the data
necessary to develop modeling and simulation tools could in
principle be derived (7,8).
XPS, Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) and Raman (or
micro-Raman) provide complementary data on the InP
surfaces. XPS allows to estimate the surface stoichiometry
278
WP3
1:30 pm – 3:30 pm
0-7803-9558-1/06/$20.00 ©2006 IEEE