Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Parkinson’s Disease
Volume 2013, Article ID 572134, 9 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2013/572134
Research Article
Exploring Outcome Measures for Exercise Intervention in
People with Parkinson’s Disease
L. A. King,
1,2
A. Salarian,
1
M. Mancini,
1
K. C. Priest,
1
J. Nutt,
1
A. Serdar,
3
J. Wilhelm,
3
J. Schlimgen,
3
M. Smith,
3
and F. B. Horak
1
1
Department of Neurology, Oregon Health and Science University, Portland, OR 97239-3098, USA
2
Parkinson Center of Oregon, OP32, 3181 S.W. Sam Jackson Park Road, Portland, OR 97239-3098, USA
3
Department of Rehabilitation Services, Oregon Health and Science University, Portland, OR 97239-3098, USA
Correspondence should be addressed to L. A. King; kingla@ohsu.edu
Received 12 February 2013; Accepted 28 March 2013
Academic Editor: Terry Ellis
Copyright © 2013 L. A. King et al. his is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Background. It is widely believed that exercise improves mobility in people with Parkinson’s disease (PD). However, it is diicult
to determine whether a speciic type of exercise is the most efective. he purpose of this study was to determine which outcome
measures were sensitive to exercise intervention and to explore the efects of two diferent exercise programs for improving mobility
in patients with PD. Methods. Participants were randomized into either the Agility Boot Camp (ABC) or treadmill training; 4x/week
for 4 weeks. Outcome measures were grouped by the International Classiication of Function/Disability (ICF). To determine the
responsiveness to exercise, we calculated the standardized response means. -tests were used to compare the relative beneits of each
exercise program. Results. Four of ive variables at the structure/function level changed ater exercise: turn duration ( = 0.03),
stride velocity ( = 0.001), peak arm speed ( = 0.001), and horizontal trunk ROM during gait ( = 0.02). Most measures
improved similarly for both interventions. he only variable that detected a diference between groups was postural sway in ABC
group ( = 4.95; = 0.03). Conclusion. Outcome measures at ICF body structure/function level were most efective at detecting
change ater exercise and revealing diferences in improvement between interventions.
1. Introduction
he progression of Parkinson’s disease (PD) inevitably results
in problems of balance, contributing to injuries, loss of mob-
ility, increased health costs, and decline in quality of life.
Delaying and minimizing these inevitable complications of
PD with physical therapy exercise would have a major impact
on patients and their families’ quality of life, healthcare sys-
tems, and possibly even the course of disease progression.
Exercise has received much attention in the past decade
as a way to delay the onset of mobility disability and there are
a steadily increasing number of randomized controlled trials
demonstrating that varying types of exercise improve some
aspects of balance or gait [1–12]. However, it is diicult to
determine whether a speciic type of exercise program is more
efective than another. One recurring obstacle, which makes
it diicult to compare treatment approaches, is that studies
use diferent types of outcome measures [13]. In addition,
exercise studies almost always compare their favored type
of intervention with a placebo or no intervention, rather
than a head-to-head comparison of diferent types of exercise
programs. he diiculty in comparing 2 potentially efective
rehabilitation interventions is the need for very sensitive tests
of change and a large number of subjects to diferentiate
exercise programs.
Although there is evidence from the animal literature
that diferent exercise protocols result in diferent efects on
synaptic and structural proteins in the brain, diferentiat-
ing functional improvements in humans ater diferent types
of exercise has been more diicult to demonstrate [14]. For
example, studies in rodents made Parkinsonian from 6-
hydroxydopamine show that aerobic exercise on a treadmill
results in increased angiogenesis whereas agility exercise that
provides a mental challenge results in more synaptic plast-
icity [15]. However, a recent meta-analysis of human exercise
studies could not distinguish relative beneits among the