Adaptive Puncturing and Rate Selection in Single-Codeword Turbo-Coded
OFDMA
Mai Abdelhakim
Center for Wireless
Studies
Faculty of Engineering
Cairo University
Egypt
Mohammed Nafie
Wireless Intelligent
Networks Center
Nile University
Egypt
Ahmed Shalash
Center for Wireless
Studies
Faculty of Engineering
Cairo University
Egypt
Ayman Y. Elezabi
Electronics Engineering.
Department
American University in
Cairo
Egypt
Abstract
This paper proposes using adaptive puncturing for
rate-adaptive OFDMA systems utilizing turbo codes.
The scheme is based on adaptively puncturing a Single
Code Word (SCW) and hence adaptively changing the
rate within the codeword. We compare the SCW
against the Multiple Code-Words (MCWs) scheme
where different rates are obtained by separate
encoding, puncturing, and interleaving on a per-tile
basis. Noticeable gains are obtained over the MCW
scheme due to the use of larger turbo block sizes and
hence larger interleavers. The SCW has around 1dB
gain in goodput compared to MCWs, with much
improved BER performance. We also propose a novel
rate selection scheme for the SCW which we call
Recursive Mutual Information Effective SNR mapping
(R-MIESM) and compare it against the conventional
MIESM scheme. The R-MIESM provides further
goodput performance gains for the SCW compared to
the MIESM method.
I. Introduction
Due to the varying nature of wireless channels, it is
inefficient to have fixed transmission parameters
during wireless communications. Allocation of
resources should be adapted according to the channel
variations in order to have efficient utilization of the
available spectrum and consequently improve overall
system throughput.
Various schemes for adapting to the wireless
environment have been studied in the literature. In [1],
changing the modulation during transmission
according to the channel quality is proposed, where
5dB gain over fixed transmission is obtained. In [2],
Chua and Goldsmith proposed a variable rate variable
transmit power adaptive scheme which obtains 5-10dB
gain over the variable power fixed rate scheme, and
20dB gain over the non adaptive transmission.
Adaptive modulation and coding (AMC) offers higher
performance gains. Adaptive trellis-coded modulation
and turbo-coded modulation were studied in [3] and [4]
respectively, and it was shown that 3dB gain is
obtained by the adaptive turbo-coded modulation over
the adaptive eight-state trellis-coded modulation [4].
AMC is employed in OFDM systems where a sub-
carrier by sub-carrier loading is proposed in [5] and the
modulation order is varied for each sub-carrier
according to the channel frequency response. The sub-
carrier loading schemes improve the performance
significantly compared to the non-adaptive OFDM
systems. However, a huge overhead is required for
such schemes. Less efficient, though still powerful,
loading is to have a tile (resource blocks) adaptation,
where a tile is a group of sub-carriers over consecutive
OFDM symbols [6 – 8].
In adaptation on a per-tile basis, also referred to as
zone loading, the transmission parameters are varied
from one tile to the other according to the channel
quality of each tile. In [6], adaptive modulation over
tiles is introduced. In [7-8] adapting the code rate and
the modulation scheme for each tile is investigated.
In [7-8], the Multiple Codewords (MCWs)
structure is used where the codeword size is confined
to the tile size and several codewords are transmitted
for each OFDM frame. Having the code rate varies on
a per tile basis requires separate encoders for each tile.
We proposed a novel architecture for changing the
code rate in a rate-adaptive coded OFDMA system, via
adaptive puncturing in [9]. In the proposed structure
different transmission rates over tiles are obtained by
using Single CodeWord (SCW) that spans the whole
OFDM frame. The single codeword is adaptively
punctured according to the required rates over the tiles.
The SCW architecture resulted in significant
performance improvement over MCW as well as Per-
Frame Adaptation (PFA) when using convolutional
codes [9]. The gains in that case were due to the
increased frequency diversity afforded by the SCW
architecture. In this paper we further investigate the
performance of the SCW structure using Convolutional
Turbo Codes (CTC). The SCW
This work was supported in part by a grant from the Egyptian
National Telecommunications Regulatory Authority (NTRA).
2009 IEEE Mobile WiMAX Symposium
978-0-7695-3719-1/09 $25.00 © 2009 IEEE
DOI 10.1109/MWS.2009.31
174