ALD Capping Layers for Superconducting Radio Frequency Accelerator Cavities
M. J. Pellin
1
, J. W. Elam
1
, and J. F. Moore
2
,
1
Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne, Illinois 60439
2
MassThink, Naperville, Illinois 60565-3123
Superconducting radio frequency (SCRF) materials are becoming
increasingly important for a variety of applications. Applications
range from cellular phone networks to high energy physics particle
accelerators such as the International Linear Collider (ILC).
Improvement of these devices requires coherent, high purity
surface films of nanometer thickness. Here Atomic Layer
Deposition (ALD) methods are described for producing well
defined dielectric (Al
2
O
3
) films on Nb, the substrate of choice for
SCRF applications.
Introduction
Atomic layer deposition (ALD) is a thin film growth method using alternating, self
limiting reactions between gaseous precursors and a solid surface to deposit materials in
an atomic layer-by-layer fashion[1]. These attributes allow highly conformal and
uniform films with atomically abrupt interfaces to be deposited on complex, 3-
dimensional substrates such as aerogels[2], powders[3], and anodic aluminum oxide
(AAO) membranes[4]. These attributes make ALD an ideal synthesis method for
modifying SCRF cavities for particle accelerator applications. The layout of the
proposed International Linear Collider (ILC) for instance includes many kilometers of
superconducting Nb cavities held at >2 K in ultrahigh vacuum (UHV). The purity of the
interior surfaces of these Nb cavities are crucial[5] because for SCRF applications these
surfaces carry all of the considerable electrical current needed to drive ions with
acceleration gradients exceeding 35 MV/m. The cavities themselves are complex in shape
and require the unique 3-dimensional coating capability offered by the ALD method.
Nb is generally accepted as the best material for SCRF cavities. It has been chosen
because it has the highest lower critical field temperature of any known superconductor.
For type 2 superconductors, the lower critical field temperature is the phase transition
temperature below which the material becomes truly resistance free. Because cooling
these cavities is both difficult and expensive, even the slight resistance found above this
temperature is unacceptable. Unfortunately, Nb is chemically labile, forming significant
oxide layers even in UHV conditions. Moreover, the oxide is compositionally complex,
forming identifiable phases ranging from Nb
2
O
5
to Nb
2
O with properties that range from
superconducting oxides to strict dielectrics.
Although there are no reports of Nb ALD, thin films of a related superconducting
material, NbN, have been prepared by ALD[6-8]. The study of the surfaces and
morphology of ultrahigh purity Nb for use in SCRF cavities has been a recent active area
of investigation.[9-14] These recent studies demonstrate that surface and interface
segregation are crucial properties of these materials for SCRF applications since
dissipative behavior is limited in this case to the first few 100 nm’s of the material.
Moreover, preferential diffusion/segregation at grain boundary or in the near surface are
phenomena leading to large inhomogeneity in the material selvedge. Vacuum annealing
of the Nb surface leads to a surface equilibrium with surface oxidation from residual
vacuum gases being balanced by diffusion of the niobium oxide into the bulk material.
ECS Transactions, 11 (7) 23-28 (2007)
10.1149/1.2779065 ©The Electrochemical Society
23
Downloaded 04 Jun 2009 to 146.139.77.80. Redistribution subject to ECS license or copyright; see http://www.ecsdl.org/terms_use.jsp