Analysis of the ferromagnetic contribution to the susceptibility
by low field and high field methods in sedimentary rocks of the
Southern Pyrenees and Northern Ebro foreland basin (Spain)
Oscar Pueyo Anchuela,
1
Antonio M. Casas-Sainz,
1
Emilio L. Pueyo,
2
Andr es Pocov ı Juan
1
and
Andr es Gil Imaz
1
1
Grupo de investigaci on Geotransfer, Departamento de Ciencias de la Tierra, Universidad de Zaragoza, C/Pedro Cerbuna, nº 12, CP.
50.009 Zaragoza, Spain;
2
Instituto Geol ogico y Minero de Espa~ na, Unidad de Zaragoza, C/Manuel Lasala, 44 - 9º, B. 50006 Zaragoza,
Spain
ABSTRACT
Magnetic susceptibility in rocks is the sum of the contribu-
tions of different magnetic particles (paramagnetic, diamag-
netic and ferromagnetic s.l.). These contributions can be
measured at variable temperatures or at variable fields (hys-
teresis loops). Both are time-consuming techniques that can-
not be routinely used in magnetic fabrics analysis. In this
study, we propose a simplified method to determine the
ferro- and paramagnetic contributions to the susceptibility,
based on the discrete measurement of susceptibility at two
different fields (near 0 and 2.5 T). The results obtained in
samples from the Southern Pyrenees and Ebro Basin indicate
that the ferromagnetic contribution vary considerably within
homogeneous susceptibility values and within the expected
range of paramagnetic values. Standard bulk susceptibilities
higher than 200 10
À6
SI contribute significantly to the ferro-
magnetic fraction (>50% on average).
Terra Nova, 0, 1–8, 2013
Introduction
Magnetic susceptibility (v) is an
intrinsic property of the matter and
can be defined as the ratio between
the applied field and the induced
magnetization when a substance is
exposed to an external magnetic field
(v = M/B). Three main magnetic
behaviours can be expected: para-
magnetism, diamagnetism and ferro-
magnetism. Diamagnetism and
paramagnetism depend on the elec-
tronic interaction at the orbital scale,
and ferromagnetism s.l. depends on
electronic interaction at the supra-
orbital scale. Standard bulk magnetic
susceptibility in rock samples is the
addition of these behaviours. How-
ever, certain ranges of values can
shed some light on the origin of the
susceptibility: (i) negative values
between 10
À5
and 10
À9
(SI units) are
usually due to diamagnetic minerals;
(ii) positive high values between 10
À2
and 10
À3
are related to ferromagnetic
carriers; and (iii) intermediate values,
between 10
À4
and 10
À6
, lie in the
potential paramagnetic domain, due
either to a complete control of para-
magnetic particles or to different
mixtures of ferromagnetic and para-
magnetic particles.
Accurate identification of the dif-
ferent contributions is usually carried
out by: i) measurement at different
fields (analysis of susceptibility under
progressively increasing magnetic
fields; Rochette et al., 1983; Rochette
and Fillion, 1988; : Borradaile and
Werner, 1994; Richter and van der
Pluijm, 1994; Mart ın-Fern andez and
Ferr e, 2007); and ii) monitoring sus-
ceptibility changes (according to the
Curie-Weiss law) during heating/
cooling experiments (Schultz-Kru-
tisch and Heller, 1985; Rochette,
1987; Jover et al., 1989; Hrouda,
1994; Richter and van der Pluijm,
1994; Hrouda et al., 1997). These
analyses are commonly applied to a
limited number of samples, and the
results obtained are extrapolated to
groups of samples with similar lithol-
ogy, susceptibility or analogous rela-
tionships between susceptibility and
the anisotropy of the AMS ellipsoid.
In this study, we propose a system-
atic approach for the analysis of the
origin of magnetic susceptibility in
sedimentary rocks from the Southern
Pyrenees and Northern Ebro (fore-
land) basin. The study focused on
the Upper Cretaceous (marls, sand-
stones and carbonate rocks), Palaeo-
cene–Eocene (limestones, sandstones,
shales and marls) and Oligocene–
Miocene (sandstones, mudstones and
carbonates) units. Our main goal was
to classify the rock samples depend-
ing on the contribution of ferromag-
netism s.l. to the magnetic
susceptibility where to analyse: (i)
the origin of the susceptibility; (ii)
the correlation among AMS anisot-
ropy, bulk magnetic susceptibility
and susceptibility changes; and (iii)
the usefulness of the bulk susceptibil-
ity value as an indicator of origin.
The methodology is based on the
measurement and interpretation of
differences between magnetic suscep-
tibilities at high and low fields.
Methodology
Susceptibility values at low and high
fields were obtained from 245 rock
samples, using a PPMS device
(Physical Property Measurement Sys-
tem, Quantum design; http://www.
qd-international.com/) at room tem-
perature (RT; 25 °C). Measured
specimens were subsampled from
AMS standard cores with a maxi-
mum size of 1 cm, representative of
Correspondence: Óscar Pueyo Anchuela,
Ciencias de la Tierra, Universidad de Zar-
agoza, C/Pedro Cerbuna, nº 12, Zaragoza
50003, Spain. Tel.: 97 67 621 27; e-mail:
opueyo@gmail.com
© 2013 Blackwell Publishing Ltd 1
doi: 10.1111/ter.12037