ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Appropriately Screened Geriatric Chest Pain Patients in an
Observation Unit Are Not Admitted at a Higher Rate Than
Nongeriatric Patients
Troy E. Madsen, MD, Joseph Bledsoe, MD, and Philip Bossart, MD
Objective: Observation units may exclude geriatric patients (de-
fined as age 65) due to the high rate of observation failure
(admission to an inpatient unit) among these patients. We evaluated
whether geriatric patients on a chest pain protocol are admitted to an
inpatient unit from an emergency department (ED) observation unit
at a higher rate than nongeriatric patients.
Methods: This was a retrospective chart review of all patients placed
in the ED observation unit at the University of Utah Medical Center
over a 14-month period from April 2006 to June 2007. The observation
unit did not exclude geriatric patients nor did it exclude patients with a
history of coronary disease; patients were admitted per the discretion of
the attending ED physician. Patient information, including age, date of
admission, history of coronary disease (defined as a previous myocar-
dial infarction, stent, or coronary artery bypass graft), and admission to
an inpatient unit from the observation unit, was recorded. Decision to
admit to an inpatient unit was made by the consulting cardiologist.
Results were analyzed using
2
statistics.
Results: One hundred thirty-four geriatric patients were admitted to
the observation unit under the chest pain protocol during the study
period. Seventeen percent of these patients were admitted to an
inpatient unit from the observation unit versus 10.7% of the 394
chest pain patients who were under age 65 (P = 0.048). Geriatric
patients were more likely to have coronary disease (31.3%) than
nongeriatric patients (20.8%; P = 0.013). We then performed a
subanalysis on the 404 patients (92 geriatric, 312 nongeriatric) who
had no history of coronary disease. Geriatric patients without a
history of coronary disease had a 12% inpatient admission rate from
the observation unit versus a 7.7% admission rate for nongeriatric
patients without a history of coronary disease (P = 0.2).
Conclusion: Geriatric patients without a history of coronary artery
disease were admitted to an inpatient unit at a rate consistent with a
generally accepted observation failure rate of 10%. When screened
appropriately, these patients may be appropriate for chest pain
evaluation in the ED observation unit.
Key Words: chest pain, coronary disease, geriatric, observation
unit
(Crit Pathways in Cardiol 2008;7: 245–247)
I
ncreasing numbers of geriatric patients create additional
burden on the healthcare system, and emergency depart-
ment observation units (EDOUs) may present an opportunity
for relieving some of this burden. However, without signifi-
cant previous experience in observation medicine, it is diffi-
cult to know patient populations, which may be best served in
an observation unit versus admission to an inpatient unit.
Previous studies have shown that EDOUs can be suc-
cessful in managing specific patient populations, including
low risk chest pain, pediatric dehydration, and asthma.
1–7
Rel-
atively little data exist on geriatric chest pain patients (age 65)
in EDOUs. One previous study reported an increased inpatient
admission rate for geriatric patients admitted to the observation
unit for chest pain.
8
We evaluated whether geriatric patients admitted to our
observation unit under the chest pain protocol were admitted
to the hospital at increased rates compared with younger
populations. In the case in which geriatric chest pain patients
were admitted to an inpatient unit at a higher rate, we planned
to seek to identify a population among geriatric chest pain
patients, which would be appropriate for an observation unit.
METHODS
This study was a retrospective chart review of all
patients admitted to the University of Utah Medical Center
Emergency Department’s 10-bed observation unit over the
14-month period from April 1, 2006 to June 1, 2007. The
University of Utah Emergency Department is an urban emer-
gency department with more than 35,000 patient visits per
year. The observation unit is under the direction of the
emergency physicians and physician assistants.
Patients were admitted to the EDOU at the discretion of
the attending emergency physician. Inclusion criteria in-
cluded: history of chest pain with low suspicion for cardiac
etiology, normal or unchanged EKG, and stable vital signs.
Exclusion criteria for observation unit placement included:
persistent or recurrent significant chest pain, acute coronary
syndrome, significantly changed EKG or left bundle branch
From the Department of Surgery, Division of Emergency Medicine, Univer-
sity of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT.
Reprints: Troy E. Madsen, MD, University of Utah, 30 N. 1900 E. 1C26, Salt
Lake City, UT 84132. E-mail: troy.madsen@hsc.utah.edu.
Copyright © 2008 by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
ISSN: 1535-282X/08/0704-0245
DOI: 10.1097/HPC.0b013e31818efb86
Critical Pathways in Cardiology • Volume 7, Number 4, December 2008 245