Designing a Modified Hopfield Network to Solve an Economic Dispatch
Problem with Nonlinear Cost Function
Ivan Nunes da Silva, Leonardo Nepomuceno, Thiago Masson Bastos
State University of São Paulo – UNESP
UNESP/FE/DEE, CP 473, CEP 17033-360
Bauru – SP, Brazil
e-mail: ivan@feb.unesp.br
Abstract - Economic Dispatch (ED) problems have
recently been solved by artificial neural networks
approaches. In most of these dispatch models, the cost
function must be linear or quadratic. Therefore, functions
that have several minimum points represent a problem to
the simulation since these approaches have not accepted
nonlinear cost function. Another drawback pointed out in
the literature is that some of these neural approaches fail
to converge efficiently towards feasible equilibrium
points. This paper discusses the application of a modified
Hopfield architecture for solving ED problems defined by
nonlinear cost function. The internal parameters of the
neural network adopted here are computed using the
valid-subspace technique, which guarantees convergence
to equilibrium points that represent a solution for the ED
problem. Simulation results and a comparative analysis
involving a 3-bus test system are presented to illustrate
efficiency of the proposed approach.
1. INTRODUCTION
In power systems, the Economic Dispatch (ED) can be
defined as the process of allocating generation levels to the
generating units, so that the system load is supplied entirely
and most economically. Many ED approaches have been
proposed in the literature to formulate and solve this problem.
In [1] it is provided a review of the advances in such field.
The economic dispatch definition above is quite large so that
many specific optimization models applied to power system,
such as optimal power flow, unit commitment, generation
scheduling, etc., may be faced as economic dispatch models.
It must be clear however that these models vary in
complexity and have different scopes of application. The
Classic Economic Dispatch (CED) discussed in [1] and [2] is
the starting point of the ED problem. CED is concerned with
minimization of total operating costs while supplying entirely
the system demand and enforcing the limits on generation
levels. In CED procedures, the transmission network
representation is totally neglected.
Some effective applications of artificial neural networks to
the ED problem have recently been presented in the
literature. In [3] an approach trying to unify unit commitment
and generation dispatch functions is described. A hybrid
Hopfield network is adopted such that the energy function of
the Hopfield network is able to deal with discrete and
continuous terms. In [4] a Hopfield neural network is
proposed to solve CED problem with general non-convex
cost functions. The computation effort for solving the
problem is high due to large number of iterations to obtain
the optimality. In [5] an analytic Hopfield method reducing
considerably this computation effort is proposed. However
the method is not applied to non-convex cost functions. In [6]
a Hopfield model for ED problem considering prohibited
zones was developed. In [7] a neural network approach for
solving CED with transmission capacity constraints was
proposed. In [8] a restructuring of the approach described in
[7] was proposed for solving the unconstrained ED, i.e., the
ED with transmission capacity constraints and also the multi-
area ED problems. A solution to ED problems using decision
trees and considering nonlinear cost function is presented in
[9].
Most of the neural network applications described above
fail to converge efficiently towards the equilibrium points
representing the dispatch problem solutions. A careful
analysis of the results presented in some of these papers
reveals that infeasible solutions are sometimes obtained. In
the modified Hopfield approach proposed in [10] to solve
CED problem, the optimization and constraint terms involved
with problem mapping (Section 3) are treated in different
stages. The modified Hopfield approach guarantees the
network convergence to a feasible optimal solution [11]. The
problems associated with speed of convergence, depicted in
[3] and [4], were also satisfactorily handled in [10]. As
demonstrated in [11], the modified Hopfield approach is also
applicable to general non-convex cost functions; and this
includes CED problems with non-monotonically increasing
incremental cost units, such as that studied in [12].
This paper applies the modified Hopfield approach
described in [10] to solve a more representative dispatch
problem. In the problem being dealt with in this work, the
cost function includes nonlinear terms. A 3-bus test system is
used to validate the methodology discussed in this paper. The
results have pointed out that the modified Hopfield approach
is robust enough to deal also with nonlinear cost functions.
The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2, the
formulation of the dispatch problem is introduced. In Section
3, the modified Hopfield network is presented, and valid-
subspace technique, used to design the network parameters, is
described. A mapping of the economic dispatch problem with
nonlinear cost functions using the modified Hopfield
network is formulated in Section 4. In Section 5, simulation
results are presented to validate the developed approach. In
Section 6, the main conclusions about the paper are
presented.
0-7803-7278-6/02/$10.00 ©2002 IEEE