275
J. Wu, K.B. Jones, H. Li, and O.L. Loucks (eds.),
Scaling and Uncertainty Analysis in Ecology: Methods and Applications, 275–295.
© 2006 Springer. Printed in the Netherlands.
CHAPTER 15
SCALING ISSUES IN MAPPING RIPARIAN ZONES WITH
REMOTE SENSING DATA:
Quantifying Errors and Sources of Uncertainty
THOMAS P. HOLLENHORST, GEORGE E. HOST, AND
LUCINDA B. JOHNSON
15.1 INTRODUCTION
Riparian zones are the ecotones or transition areas between upland and aquatic
ecosystems, located at the margins of rivers, lakes, ponds and wetlands. Their
boundaries are defined by changes in soil, moisture, and vegetation (Naiman 2000,
Décamps 1996, Gregory et al. 1991). Although these ecosystems may be small
relative to the aquatic systems they abut, they perform many important ecosystem
services, including shading (thus buffering air and water temperature), retaining
nutrients and/or sediments, stabilizing stream banks and littoral zones, and providing
organic material (leaves, wood) and critical habitat for a diverse community of plant
and animal species (Malanson 1993). Riparian zones are highly variable systems
whose structure and composition are shaped by geomorphology, vegetation patterns,
disturbance regimes (Décamps 1996), as well as current (Erickson and DeYoung
1993) and perhaps historic land use practices (Foster et al. 2003). Processes that
operate over a large range of temporal and spatial scales control these structuring
factors. At one end of the time/space continuum are processes such as tectonics,
volcanism, glaciation, and climate change. At intermediate spatial and temporal
scales are historic land use practices (e.g., burning regimes implemented by native
peoples, permanent land cover conversion) and catastrophic flooding. At small
scales, localized flooding and land management practices influence the structure and
function of riparian zones. Some processes occur over multiple scales and their
effects may also vary by scale.
The fine-scale variation of vegetative cover resulting from moisture and soil
gradients around streams and wetlands has posed a challenge to research scientists
and land managers (Muller 1997, Congalton et al. 2002). One of the current