Hand-Handhold Coupling: Effect of Handle Shape,
Orientation, and Friction on Breakaway Strength
Justin G. Young, Charles Woolley, Thomas J. Armstrong, and James A.
Ashton-Miller, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor
Objective: The aim was to determine the maximum force that can be exerted on an object
before it is pulled or slips from the grasp of the hand (“breakaway strength”) for fixed over-
head handholds of varying orientation, shape, and friction. Background: Many studies
have quantified hand strength by having participants squeeze, pull on, or create torque on an
object or handle, but few studies have measured breakaway strength directly. Method: In
two experiments, hand strength was measured as both overhead breakaway strength for
handholds typical of fixed industrial ladders and as maximum isometric grip strength
measured using a common Jamar grip dynamometer. Results: Breakaway strength was
greatest for a fixed horizontal cylinder (“high friction”; 668 ± 40 N and 691 ± 132 N
for Experiments 1 and 2, respectively), then for a horizontal cylinder that simulated low
surface friction (“low friction”; 552 ± 104 N), then for a vertical cylinder (435 ± 27 N),
and finally, for a vertical rectangular-shaped rail (337 ± 24 N). Participants are capable of
supporting only their own body weight with one hand when grasping the fixed horizon-
tal cylinder. Breakaway strength for both the high- and low-friction horizontal cylinders
was significantly greater than isometric grip strength (1.58 ± 0.25 and 1.26 ± 0.19 times,
respectively). Conclusion: Results support the hypothesis that hand-handhold coupling
is composed of active (isometric or eccentric finger flexion) and passive (frictional) com-
ponents. Traditional isometric grip strength alone does not predict the strength of a couple
between a hand and a handhold well. Application: This research shows that handhold
shape, orientation, and friction are important in the safe design of grab rails or ladders.
Address correspondence to Justin G. Young, 1205 Beal Ave., Industrial and Operations Engineering, University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109; jgy@umich.edu. HUMAN FACTORS, Vol. 51, No. 5, October 2009, pp. 705-717.
DOI: 10.1177/0018720809355969. Copyright © 2009, Human Factors and Ergonomics Society.
INTRODUCTION
Motivation
Falls are a major cause of injury and mortal-
ity in the working-age population. The Bureau
of Labor Statistics reports that 827 fatalities
resulted from falls in U.S. workplaces in 2006,
with 77 deaths associated with falls from non-
moving vehicles, 132 from ladders, and 21
involving steps or stairs (BLS, 2007). An aver-
age of 136,118 nonfatal injuries associated with
falls from ladders are treated in U.S. emergency
rooms each year, with a 50% increase in the
number of injuries from 1990 to 2006 (D’Souza,
Smith, & Trifiletti, 2007).
Background
The hand is commonly used to help sup-
port the body by gripping handles and other
objects in the workplace. There are many situ-
ations in which a loss of hand-handhold cou-
pling can result in a fall to the same or a lower
level. Examples include climbing into or out of
heavy equipment (tractors, semitrucks), climb-
ing on ladders, hanging onto moving vehicles
(garbage truck personnel), and using safety rails
(stairways, scaffolding, bathroom grab rails)
(Barnett & Poczynck, 2000; Bottoms, 1983). In
many of these situations, if the individual were
to slip or fall, his or her weight would be trans-
ferred suddenly from the feet to the hands, and
the strength of the couple between the hand and
the handhold being grasped would determine
whether the individual will support his or her
body weight or lose grip of the handhold and
be injured.
The hand is also the interface that allows
workers to hold and use work objects, such as