Optimal Bayesian Experimental Design for
Combustion Kinetics
Xun Huan
∗
and Youssef Marzouk
†
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, 02139, USA
Experimental diagnostics play an essential role in the development and refinement of
chemical kinetic models, whether for the combustion of common complex hydrocarbons
or of emerging alternative fuels. Questions of experimental design—e.g., which variables
or species to interrogate, at what resolution and under what conditions—are extremely
important in this context, particularly when experimental resources are limited. This paper
attempts to answer such questions in arigorous and systematic way. We propose a Bayesian
framework for optimal experimental design with nonlinear simulation-based models. While
the framework is broadly applicable, we use it to infer rate parameters in a combustion
system with detailed kinetics. The framework introduces a utility function that reflects the
expected information gain from a particular experiment. Straightforward evaluation (and
maximization) of this utility function requires Monte Carlo sampling, which is infeasible
with computationally intensive models. Instead, we construct a polynomial surrogate for
the dependence of experimental observables on model parameters and design conditions,
with the help of dimension-adaptive sparse quadrature. Results demonstrate the efficiency
and accuracy of the surrogate, as well as the considerable effectiveness of the experimental
design framework in choosing informative experimental conditions.
I. Introduction
An increasingly broad range of fuels, derived from diverse feedstocks, are shaping future transportation
and power generation systems. In the realm of ground transportation, biofuels are entering the fuel supply
in blends with conventional petroleum-derived fuels and as primary energy carriers. Alternative aviation
fuels—synthesized through gasification and liquefaction processes from biomass, coal, natural gas, tar sands,
and oil shale—are of great interest to engine and airframe manufacturers. Environmental requirements
often dictate that these fuels be coupled with high-efficiency energy conversion technologies designed to
minimize pollutant emissions. Emerging strategies include low-temperature combustion in homogeneous
charge compression ignition (HCCI) engines, direct injection in spark-ignition (SI) engines, or staged ultra-
lean combustion in gas turbines. Yet the consumption of alternative fuels in these systems involves chemical
species and blends whose physical properties and combustion kinetics are poorly characterized. Additionally,
new engines and propulsion technologies may operate in low temperature or extreme pressure regimes where
current kinetic models—even for widely-used fuels, much less alternative fuels—are not validated.
Myriad sources of data contribute to reaction mechanisms and thermophysical properties. Ignition ex-
periments, flow reactor experiments, and flame speed measurements are important, yet indirect, targets for
developing and validating kinetic mechanisms. Optical diagnostics are essential to focused experimental
studies of gas-phase combustion kinetics, but high pressure environments and direct interrogation of large
molecules present significant challenges. Ab initio calculations, on the other hand, are limited in scale, and
results often must be extrapolated to larger species or to faraway pressures and temperatures, with unknown
levels of confidence. The rapid development of new fuels and new conversion technologies urges more sys-
tematic approaches to model development that synthesize all these sources of kinetic information, including
indirect data such as ignition delays and flame speeds.
∗
Graduate Student, Department of Aeronautics and Astronautics, 77 Massachusetts Ave., 37-442, Cambridge, MA 02139,
AIAA Student Member.
†
Assisstant Professor, Department of Aeronautics and Astronautics, 77 Massachusetts Ave., 33-305, Cambridge, MA 02139,
AIAA Senior Memmber.
1 of 16
American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics
49th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting including the New Horizons Forum and Aerospace Exposition
4 - 7 January 2011, Orlando, Florida
AIAA 2011-513
Copyright © 2011 by Xun Huan and Youssef Marzouk. Published by the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Inc., with permission.