Catalysis Today 79–80 (2003) 181–188
Intensification of bubble columns by vibration excitement
J. Ellenberger, J.M. van Baten, R. Krishna
∗
Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Amsterdam, Nieuwe Achtergracht 166, 1018 WV Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Abstract
In this paper we show that application of low-frequency vibrations, in the 40–120 Hz range, to the liquid phase of an air–water
bubble column causes significantly smaller bubbles to be generated at the nozzle. In experiments with a single capillary nozzle,
the bubble size is reduced by about 40–50%, depending on the vibration frequency and amplitude. CFD simulations show
that the vibrations tend to lead to earlier detachment of the bubbles from the nozzles, leading to smaller bubble sizes.
Using a 12-capillary nozzle arrangement, the gas holdup, ε, was measured for a range of superficial gas velocities. Ap-
plication of vibrations to the liquid phase leads to a significant increase in the gas holdup. The increase in the gas holdup is
attributed mainly to a significant reduction in the rise velocity of the bubble swarm due to the generation of standing waves in
the column. Furthermore, application of vibrations to the liquid phase serves to stabilize the homogenous bubbly flow regime
and delay the onset of the churn-turbulent flow regime.
© 2003 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Bubble column; Vibration excitement; Process intensification; Gas holdup; Standing waves
1. Introduction
A bubble column reactor is commonly used in
the process industries for carrying out a variety of
liquid phase reactions [1]. There are two regimes
of operation for a bubble column. At low superfi-
cial gas velocities, U, we have homogeneous bubbly
flow in which the dispersion consists of bubbles that
are roughly uniform in size. Homogeneous bubbly
flow is sustainable up to a superficial gas velocity
U = U
trans
, called the transition gas velocity. When
U is increased to values beyond U
trans
, we enter the
heterogeneous or churn-turbulent flow regime. In this
churn-turbulent flow regime, we have a wide dis-
tribution of bubble sizes, ranging from 3 to 50 mm
depending on the system properties [2]. The wide
∗
Corresponding author. Tel.: +31-20-525-7007;
fax: +31-20-525-5604.
E-mail address: krishna@science.uva.nl (R. Krishna).
distribution of bubble sizes causes a wide gas phase
residence time distribution; this is often detrimental
to reactor conversion and selectivity.
Uniformity of bubble sizes in gas–liquid reactors
can be achieved by means of mechanical agita-
tion or stirring. However, the stirring action of the
agitator causes intense backmixing of both liquid
and gas phases. In some biotechnological applica-
tions, the high shear, experienced near the agitator,
is undesirable. The major objective of the present
communication is to demonstrate the advantages
of a shaken or vibrated bubble column reactor in
which the liquid phase is subjected to low-frequency
vibrations in the 40–120 Hz range. A special vi-
bration excitement device is used for this purpose.
The advantage of using low-frequency vibrations
over mechanical agitation is that the plug flow char-
acter of the bubbles is maintained and no addi-
tional large-scale backmixing of the liquid phase is
induced.
0920-5861/03/$ – see front matter © 2003 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/S0920-5861(03)00003-8