Proceedings of International Joint Conference on Neural Networks, Orlando, Florida, USA, August 12-17, 2007
A hybrid Support Vector Machine and autoregressive model for
detecting gait disorders in the elderly
Daniel T.H. Lai, Ahsan Khandoker, Rezaul K. Begg and M.Palaniswami
Abstract- The consequence of tripping and falling in the
elderly population is serious because of the life threatening
fractures which occur and the high medical costs incurred.
Recently, the minimum toe clearance (MTC) has been employed
in gait analysis as a sensitive gait variable for early detection
of elderly people at risk of falling. In previous work, we
successfully applied statistical and wavelet analysis methods
with Support Vector Machines (SVM) to model the risk of
tripping in the elderly. In this work, we propose to model
the MTC time series as a wide based stationary random
signal using the autoregressive (AR) process. Initially, it was
found that a fourth order AR model constructed from 512
MTC samples per subject on 23 subjects completely modelled
the balance impaired gait (pathological) from normal gait.
However, when the number of MTC samples were reduced
to 32, the two groups became inseparable. We then proposed
a hybrid system consisting of a SVM classifier with AR model
coefficients as input features to separate the two classes. It was
found that SVMs with linear and Gaussian kernels produced
100% leave one out accuracies without the need for prior
feature selection algorithms. In contrast, SVM models built
previously from the best set of wavelet features produced only
86.95% leave one out accuracies. These results suggest that
pathological gait is best modelled by the AR process if sufficient
MTC data is available. In the case of shorter MTC data, the
AR model still provides powerful and robust discriminative
features which can be used by the SVM to detect elderly people
at risk of falling.
I. INTRODUCTION
The ageing population of highly industrialized countries
such as Australia is on the rise. It is estimated that by
the year 2035, 22% of the Australian population will be
aged over 65 years [1] compared to just 12% in 2005. This
forecasted increase requires continuous improvements to the
current health care system to cope with the pathologies or
diseases that may affect the elderly population. One of the
more common afflictions in this age group is falls. Falling
is a serious health problem known to affect 53% [2] of the
elderly population with tripping and slipping being the major
etiologies i.e., 83% of elderly falls [3]. Trip related falls
potentially result in life threatening fractures and are known
to cost the Australian government approximately 2.4 billion
AUD [4] annually in injury costs. Research in automated
detection and diagnosis of those at risk of falling is therefore
essential so that preventive or rehabilitative measures can be
taken.
Daniel T.H. Lai, Ahsan Khandoker and M.Palaniswami are with the
Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, The University of
Melbourne, Parkville Campus, Vic 3010, Australia (phone: +61-3-8344
4942; email: d.lai
0ee.unimelb.edu.au
).
Rezaul K. Begg is with the Centre for Ageing, Rehabilitation, Exercise
and Sport, Victoria University, Vic 8001, Australia.
It has been proven that ageing changes gait patterns which
destabilize the human locomotion balance mechanism. Falls
due to tripping in the elderly are the result of declines
in the balance control function due to ageing [5], [6].
Numerous studies undertaken in recent years focussed on
identifying suitable gait variables that are affected as a
result of the ageing process and also those that best indicate
declines in gait performance. Contemporary gait variables
using kinematics e.g., measurements of joint angles [7]-[10]
and kinetics such as time-distance variables (e.g., walking
speed, stance/swing times, step length) have long been used
to identify key characteristics of gait degeneration in the
elderly. Pavol et. al [11] have studied mechanisms leading
to falls in the elderly and the natural recovery strategies
employed to prevent falling. Barak et al. [12] investigated
the variance of kinematic variables such as stride frequency,
stride length, walking speed, lateral body sway etc. as likely
causes of falling. Both these studies and several others
have concluded that large variations in gait variables are
risk indicators of falling, however it is still unknown as to
whether they directly affect tripping or if tripping is actually
the result of body adjustments to avoid future falls.
Recently, a more sensitive gait variable known as mini-
mum toe clearance (MTC) has been used to describe age-
related declines in gait with better success as a predictor
of falls risk [13], [14]. MTC during walking (see Fig. 1) is
defined as the minimum vertical distance between the lowest
point on the shoe and the ground during the mid-swing
phase of the gait cycle. This variable is important because
it determines successful negotiation of the environment in
which we walk. The literature has also suggested a decrease
in MTC height (1. 1 cm) with ageing [6], thereby providing
a strong rationale for MTC being associated with tripping
during walking.
5 9 13 17 21 25 29 33 37 41 45 49 53 57 61 65 69 73 77
Time (10ms)
Fig. 1. Left foot (toe) clearance over the swing phase showing the MTC
event in one gait cycle.
In previous work, SVM models based on statistical [15]
1-4244-1 380-X/07/$25.00 ©2007 IEEE
E
E
.0
a
MTC
Ground
Level