Double-Concave Binding of Bicorannulenyl Dianion: Cesium vs
Lithium Salts
Natalie J. Sumner,
†
Sarah N. Spisak,
†
Alexander S. Filatov,
†
Andrey Yu. Rogachev,
‡
Alexander V. Zabula,
§
and Marina A. Petrukhina*
,†
†
Department of Chemistry, University at Albany, State University of New York, Albany, New York 12222, United States
‡
Department of Biological and Chemical Sciences, Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago, Illinois 60616, United States
§
Department of Chemistry, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin 53706, United States
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: The first X-ray structural characterization of bicorannulenyl
dianion has been accomplished for two alkali metal salts,
[Li
+
(THF)
4
]
2
[C
40
H
18
2-
] (1) and [Cs
+
(18-crown-6)]
2
[C
40
H
18
2-
] (2).
This crystallographic study revealed the biaryl stereochemistry, geometry
transformation upon acquiring two electrons, and different binding
preferences of Li
+
vs Cs
+
ions in the solid-state products.
T
he design and synthesis of extended π-systems utilizing
bowl-shaped polyarenes as functional building units has
become a new research direction in recent years.
1,2
Varying the
length and nature of the linkage between the curved fragments
is effectively used to alter the electronic coupling and
supramolecular oligomerization behavior, giving rise to new
properties and interesting applications of the resulting carbon-
rich compounds. The small bowl-shaped polyarene corannu-
lene (C
20
H
10
) is commonly used for such applications due to its
availability based on the well-developed preparation methods.
3
Using corannulene pincers, remarkable molecular receptors
have been prepared with unique molecular recognition toward
fullerene binding based on complementary convex-concave
π-π stacking interactions.
4
Fusion of corannulene units to
anion-responsive π-conjugated molecules afforded novel self-
organized molecular materials with enhanced charge carrier
mobility.
5
Self-assembly of π-bowls coupled with redox-active
organometallic spacers in corannulenylferrocenes and suma-
neylferrocenes has also been explored.
6
Direct aryl-aryl coupling of two corannulene bowls affords
bicorannulenyl (C
40
H
18
, Scheme 1), which exhibits a novel
chirality and unique dynamic stereochemistry elucidated by
Shenhar’s group using variable-temperature NMR spectroscopy
and DFT calculations.
7
Recently, such isomerism was also
found by Hirao and co-workers for bisumanenyl, having two
linked sumanene (C
21
H
12
) bowls.
8
The redox properties of
such extended aromatic systems composed of coupled bowl-
shaped fragments, known to be excellent individual reservoirs
for multiple electrons,
9
are especially interesting.
10
The
reduction of bicorannulenyl has been previously investigated
using solution NMR spectroscopy augmented by DFT
calculations.
11
The in-depth investigation of the stereodynamics
of bicorannulenyl dianion revealed 13 stable conformations: six
pairs of enantiomers and a single achiral isomer (PM
180
). Such
flexibility led to problems with unequivocal interpretation of
NMR data for the in situ formed bicorannulenyl dianion. While
there are three stable diastereomers that are more energetically
favorable, the PM
180
isomer was proposed to be the major
species existing in solution. On the basis of the bond-order
considerations, it was also predicted that the single bond
tethering two corannulene units in bicorannulenyl should gain
substantial double-bond character upon acquisition of two
electrons, converting it to a charged overcrowded ethylene
(Scheme 1).
11
Until now, no solid-state products of charged
bicorannulenyl have been reported to give further insights on
the stereochemistry and geometry transformation of C
40
H
18
upon acquiring extra electrons.
In this work, we targeted the isolation of crystalline products
of bicorannulenyl dianion in order to perform its first
crystallographic investigation and to evaluate its metal-binding
properties. We selected lithium and cesium for this study, as
these two alkali metals show distinctly different binding
preferences toward corannulene anions. While lithium ions
Received: April 14, 2014
Published: May 21, 2014
Scheme 1. Transformation of Bicorannulenyl upon
Reduction to Dianion
Article
pubs.acs.org/Organometallics
© 2014 American Chemical Society 2874 dx.doi.org/10.1021/om500396m | Organometallics 2014, 33, 2874-2878