Model Validation: Robot Behavior in People Guidance Mission using
DTM model and Estimation of Human Motion Behavior.
Ana´ ıs Garrell and Alberto Sanfeliu
Institut de Rob` otica i Inform` atica Industrial (CSIC-UPC)
08028 Barcelona, Spain
Abstract— This paper describes the validation process of
a simulation model that have been used to explore the new
possibilities of interaction when humans are guided by teams
of robots that work cooperatively in urban areas. The set of
experiments, which have been recorded as video sequences,
show a group of people being guided by a team of three people
(who play the role of the guide robots). The model used in
the simulation process is called Discrete Time Motion model
(DTM) described in [7], where the environment is modeled
using a set of potential fields, and people’s motion is represented
through tension functions. The video sequences were recorded
in an urban space of 10.000 m
2
denominated Barcelona Robot
Lab, where people move in the urban space following diverse
trajectories. The motion (pose and velocity) of people and robots
extracted from the video sequences were compared against
the predictions of the DTM model. Finally, we checked the
proper functioning of the model by studying the position error
differences of the recorded and simulated sequences.
I. INTRODUCTION
Nowadays, research community have increased its interest
in robots performing social tasks, consequently the needed of
studying new abilities for human-robot interaction and task
cooperation have become important issues. One application
where these abilities are shown is in guiding a group of
people using one or several robots [4]. Some experiments of
guiding people with one robot have been already performed,
but when is a group of people guided by a team of robots, the
experiments are not performed easily due to the limitations
of the present technology (robots do not move or change
their orientation fast enough). In these situations is better to
simulate the experiments and then validate the results using
sequence of real guided missions [2].
In this work, we present the validation of a model
described previously in [7], denominated “Discrete-Time-
Motion” model (DTM). The DTM model is a new approach
for guiding people in open areas of urban settings using
multiple robots acting in a cooperative way. One of the robots
is the leader, and acts as a human tour-guide. It is placed at
the front of the formation and its role is to estimate the
trajectory of both people and the rest of robots. The other
robots, called shepherd, are responsible for guiding people,
This research was conducted at the Institut de Rob` otica i Inform` atica
Industrial (CSIC-UPC). It was partially supported by CICYT projects
DPI2007-61452 and Ingenio Consolider CSD2007-018, by CSIC project
200850I055 and by IST-045062 of European Community. The first author
acknowledges Spanish FPU grant ref. AP2006-00825.
Fig. 1. (a), (b) and (c) show different captions of the guided group by the
camera network. (d) shows an aerial view of the experimental site, Barcelona
Robot Lab, including the distribution of camera network, and the trajectory
of the group in one of the experiments.
preventing any person leaving the group, and following the
path given by the leader. The DTM model represents robots,
people and obstacles by means of potential functions, and it
computes the estimations of people’s and robots positions.
The model uses a particle filter [1] for positions estimation,
and it considers Helbing equations [8], [9] for the simulation
of human reactions in front of different stimulus that come
from the robots and the constraints of the environment.
The works presented in the literature show their contri-
butions for groups of robots that interact with people using
simulations. For instance, [6] performs a qualitative analysis
of the movements of different entities –such as humans or
animals– and build an architecture of three robots to guide
them. However, realistic situations, such as the existence
of obstacles or dealing with people leaving the group are
not considered, and their models were not validated. In [13]
several types of robot formations and different strategies for
approaching the robots to people are considered. However.
all these issues and the general movements of the robots
are ruled by a large number of heuristics which makes the
system impractical. Furthermore, in order to achieve the
The 2010 IEEE/RSJ International Conference on
Intelligent Robots and Systems
October 18-22, 2010, Taipei, Taiwan
978-1-4244-6676-4/10/$25.00 ©2010 IEEE 5836