A Randomized Controlled Trial of a Couple Relationship and Coparenting
Program (Couple CARE for Parents) for High- and Low-Risk New Parents
Jemima F. Petch
Relationships Australia Queensland, Eight Miles Plains,
Queensland, Australia
W. Kim Halford and Debra K. Creedy
University of Queensland
Jenny Gamble
Griffith University
Objective: This study evaluated the effectiveness of couple relationship education in assisting couples to
sustain relationship functioning and parenting sensitivity, and whether benefits were moderated by risk
of maladjustment in the transition to parenthood (“risk”). Method: Two hundred fifty couples expecting
their first child were assessed on risk and randomly assigned to either the Couple CARE for Parents (CCP),
a couple relationship- and coparenting-focused education program (n = 125), or the Becoming a Parent
Program (BAP), a mother-focused parenting program (n = 125). Couples completed assessments of their
couple relationship during pregnancy, after intervention at 4 months postpartum, and at 16 and 28 months
postpartum. Observed parenting and self-report parenting stress were assessed at 4 months postpartum, and
parenting stress was assessed again at 16 and 28 months postpartum. Results: Risk was associated with greater
relationship and parenting adjustment problems. Relative to BAP, CCP women decreased their negative
communication and showed a trend to report less parenting stress irrespective of risk level. High-risk women
receiving CCP reported higher relationship satisfaction, and were less intrusive in their parenting, than
high-risk women receiving BAP. There were no effects of CCP on sensitive parenting and parenting
intrusiveness for women. High-risk men in CCP showed a trend for higher relationship satisfaction than
high-risk BAP men, but there were no effects of CCP for men on any parenting outcomes. Conclusions: CCP
is a potentially useful intervention, but benefits are primarily for high-risk women.
Keywords: couple relationship education, transition to parenthood, high risk, couples, intervention
Couple relationship education (CRE) aimed at first-time parents
(perinatal CRE) reduces the decline in relationship satisfaction
observed across the transition to parenthood (Petch & Halford,
2008). However, the effect sizes are modest (Pinquart & Teubert,
2010), and perhaps only some couples benefit from CRE. Further-
more, the effects of CRE on parenting are unknown. In the present
study, we evaluated the effects of the Couple CARE for Parents
(CCP) program (Halford, Petch, & Creedy, 2010) on the couple
relationship and parenting and whether those effects were moder-
ated by couples’ risk of poor adjustment.
Challenges in the Transition to Parenthood
The transition to parenthood is joyous but challenging for most
couples (Gottman & Notarius, 2000) and is a high-risk time for
development of couple relationship distress (Cowan & Cowan,
2000; Mitnick, Heyman, & Slep, 2009). Whereas parent and
nonparent couples show a similar average decline in relationship
satisfaction across the first decade of marriage (Mitnick et al.,
2009), new parent couples show a sudden and marked decline after
the birth of their first child (Doss, Rhoades, Stanley, & Markman,
2009). The sudden decline for new parents is likely due, at least in
part, to the challenging demands of infant care and the 45+ hr per
week of additional household tasks that accompany parenthood
(Petch & Halford, 2008). Couples vary greatly in the extent to
which they cope effectively with these challenges, with 40%–50%
of couples showing a substantial decline in relationship satisfac-
tion across the transition to parenthood (Doss et al., 2009). Wom-
en’s relationship satisfaction is more affected by having a child
than men’s, and is particularly low when parenting young children
(Twenge, Campbell, & Foster, 2003).
This article was published Online First June 25, 2012.
Jemima F. Petch, Relationships Australia Queensland, Eight Miles
Plains, Queensland, Australia; W. Kim Halford and Debra K. Creedy,
Department of Psychology, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Queens-
land, Australia; Jenny Gamble, Department of Psychology, Griffith Uni-
versity, South Brisbane, Queensland, Australia.
This research was supported by National Health and Medical Research
Council of Australia Grant 326321 “A Randomized Controlled Trial of a
Couple-Based Program for the Transition to Parenthood,” awarded to W.
Kim Halford and Debra K. Creedy. W. Kim Halford is the first author of
the Couple CARE progrom from which the Couple CARE for Parents
program evaluated in the present article was developed. Couple CARE is
published and distributed by Australian Academic Press, and he receives
royalties from those sales. We thank Charles Farrugia, Vivian Jarrett, and
Christopher Pepping for help with data collection and Joanne Fisher,
Teresa Walsh, Corinne Mawn, Leesa Cunningham, Melinda Bentley, Jac-
qui Hudson, Alison Brennan, Lianne Schwartz, and Di Tamariki for their
work as the nurse-midwife relationship educators.
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Jemima
F. Petch, Relationships Australia Queensland, Technology Office Park,
13/107 Miles Platting Road, Eight Miles Plains, QLD 4113, Australia.
E-mail: j.petch@uq.edu.au
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology © 2012 American Psychological Association
2012, Vol. 80, No. 4, 662– 673 0022-006X/12/$12.00 DOI: 10.1037/a0028781
662