660 NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY VOL 17 JULY 1999 http://biotech.nature.com
RESEARCH
Aberrant glycosylation is fundamental to tumor progression, since
cells acquire competence for metastasis and a faster clonal growth
through newly synthesized carbohydrate structures
1
. Tumor-
expressed carbohydrate antigens are therefore considered important
targets for active specific and passive immunotherapy, and carbohy-
drate-based cancer vaccines are under investigation to modulate
immune responses to carbohydrate antigens both qualitatively and
quantitatively
2
. Carbohydrates, however, are typically poorly
immunogenic, difficult to purify in large quantities, difficult to syn-
thesize, and usually result in mostly short-lived IgM-type antibodies
in a vaccinated host without long-lasting immunity. Additionally,
most carbohydrate antigens are T-cell independent, reflecting their
inability to stimulate MHC class II–dependent T-cell help
3
.
Consequently, carbohydrates by themselves do not elicit a sufficient
anamnestic or secondary immune response leading to the develop-
ment of polysaccharide–protein conjugates
2,4
.
Molecular mimicry of carbohydrate antigens as a means to con-
vert the T-cell–independent response to a T-cell–dependent one is
an attractive alternative. The idea of using surrogate antigens as
immunogens requires that antigenic mimicry, accomplished using
amino acids in place of sugars, elicits an immune specificity pattern
for the nominal antigen. Anti-idiotypic antibodies
5
and peptides
that mimic tumor-associated carbohydrate (TAC) antigens
6–8
or
their glycosphingolipid constituents
9
have been described. Here, we
demonstrate that designed peptides that consist of carbohydrate-
mimicking motifs presented as multiple-antigen peptides (MAPs)
are effective at eliciting (primarily) IgM antibody responses in mice
that react with neolactoseries-expressing human and murine tumor
cells. The anti-peptide serum mediates complement-dependent-
cytotoxicity (CDC) of human breast tumor cells that express the
neolactoseries antigen Lewis Y (LeY) in the presence of human com-
plement as effectively as or more effectively than serum provoked by
synthetic LeY. The effectiveness of peptide mimotopes as priming
agents is an anticipated requirement for longer-lasting immune
responses. Although there is no adequate in vivo tumor model for
LeY since this antigen is not expressed on murine tumor cells, a sia-
lylated homolog Lewis X (sLeX) is expressed on Meth A fibrosarco-
ma tumor on a Balb/c background. Vaccination with peptide mimo-
topes diminishes tumor growth in vivo in graded Meth A tumor
challenge studies.
Results
Immunogenic mimicry of peptide motifs. Epitope mapping tech-
niques have repeatedly demonstrated that antibodies bind to epi-
topes of three to five amino acids within a sequence. The fine speci-
ficity of some carbohydrate-binding proteins maps to peptides con-
taining central W/YXY residues. Peptides with the generalized aro-
matic motif W/YXY are defined to mimic several carbohydrate sub-
units. These include YPY as a mimic of mannose
10,11
, WRY found to
mimic a(1–4) glucose
12
, WLY to mimic LeY
6
, and YRY as a mimic of
the major C polysaccharide a(2–9) sialic acid (MCP) of Neisseria
meningitidis
13
. This generalized-motif feature is associated with pep-
tides that are defined as mimics of glycosphingolipid constituents
9
.
The neolactoseries structures Lewis X (LeX), sLeX, Lewis a (Lea),
sialyl-Lea (sLea) and Lewis b (Leb) all share a common epitope
topography
14
with constituents that are structurally similar to carbo-
hydrates that are mimicked by the W/YXY motif
15
. Consequently,
Vaccination with carbohydrate peptide
mimotopes promotes anti-tumor
responses
Thomas Kieber-Emmons
1*
, Ping Luo
1
, Jianping Qiu
1
, Tylis Y. Chang
1
, Insug O
2
,
Magdalena Blaszczyk-Thurin
2
, and Zenon Steplewski
3
1
Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia PA. 19104.
2
The Wistar Institute, Philadelphia PA 19104.
3
Department of Microbiology and Immunology, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia PA 19104. *Corresponding author (tom@xray.med.upenn.edu)
Received 2 November 1998; accepted 14 April 1999
Tumor-associated carbohydrate (TAC) antigens are important targets in cancer vaccine efforts.
Carbohydrates are, however, frequently poor immunogens, in that they are T-cell–independent antigens.
Molecular mimicry of TAC by peptides is an alternative approach to generating anti-carbohydrate immune
responses. Here we demonstrate that peptide mimotopes can elicit antibody responses that cross-react
with representative human TAC antigens. Primary immunization with such a multiple antigenic peptide,
along with QS-21 as adjuvant, elicits cytotoxic antibodies reactive with naturally occurring forms of TAC
expressed on tumor cells, and vaccination of mice with peptide mimotopes reduced tumor growth and
prolonged host survival in a murine tumor model.
Keywords: vaccine, cancer, mimotype, mimic, carbohydrate, Lewis Y, Meth A
Table 1. Peptides used in these studies.
Peptide name Sequence
a
Source
105 GGIYYPY DIYYPY DIYYPY D Designed synthetic
106 GGIYWR Y DIYWR Y DIYWR Y D Designed synthetic
107 GGIYYR Y DIYYR Y DIYYR Y D Designed synthetic
104 IMILLIFSLLWFGGA Isolated from peptide
library with BR55-2
C1 GDTRYIPALQHGDKK Irrelevant control
a
The respective aromatic-X-aromatic motifs are underlined.
© 1999 Nature America Inc. • http://biotech.nature.com
© 1999 Nature America Inc. • http://biotech.nature.com