Highly Efficient Enzyme-Functionalized Porous Zirconia Microtubes
for Bacteria Filtration
Stephen Kroll,* Christoph Brandes, Julia Wehling, Laura Treccani, Georg Grathwohl,
and Kurosch Rezwan
Advanced Ceramics, University of Bremen, Am Biologischen Garten 2, 28359 Bremen, Germany
ABSTRACT: In contrast to polymer membranes, ceramic
membranes offer considerable advantages for safe drinking
water provision due to their excellent chemical, thermal, and
mechanical endurance. In this study, porous ceramic micro-
tubes made of yttria stabilized zirconia (YSZ) are presented,
which are conditioned for bacteria filtration by immobilizing
lysozyme as an antibacterial enzyme. In accordance with
determined membrane pore sizes of the nonfunctionalized
microtube of ≤200 nm, log reduction values (LRV) of nearly 3
(i.e., bacterial retention of 99.9%) were obtained for bacterial retention studies using gram-positive model bacterium Micrococcus
luteus. Immobilization studies of lysozyme on the membrane surface reveal an up to six times higher lysozyme loading for the
covalent immobilization route as compared to unspecific immobilization. Antibacterial activity of lysozyme-functionalized
microtubes was assessed by qualitative agar plate test using Micrococcus luteus as substrate showing that both the unspecific and
the covalent lysozyme immobilization enhance the microtubes’ antibacterial properties. Quantification of the enzyme activity at
flow conditions by photometric assays reveals that the enzyme activities of lysozyme-functionalized microtubes depend strongly
on applied flow rates. Intracapillary feeding of bacteria solution and higher flow rates lead to reduced enzyme activities. In
consideration of different applied flow rates in the range of 0.2-0.5 mL/min, the total lysozyme activity increases by a factor of 2
for the covalent immobilization route as compared to the unspecific binding. Lysozyme leaching experiments at flow conditions
for 1 h show a significant higher amount of washed-out lysozyme (factor 1.7-3.4) for the unspecific immobilization route when
compared to the covalent route where the initial level of antibacterial effectiveness could be achieved by reimmobilization with
lysozyme. The presented platform is highly promising for sustainable bacteria filtration.
(1). INTRODUCTION
The access to clean water is one of the fundamental
requirements for life. Today, 884 million people lack access
to safe drinking water, 2.6 billion people have little or no
sanitation, and millions of people die annually from diseases
transmitted by polluted water.
1-6
Basically, natural water can be polluted by chemical (e.g.,
organic or inorganic species), physical (e.g., color), and
biological (e.g., bacteria, viruses) contamination. Particularly,
pathogenic bacteria (e.g., Vibrio cholerae, Legionella pneumo-
philia, Salmonella typhi) are responsible for waterborne diseases
and present a direct risk to human health.
7-11
Safe drinking water is commonly provided by disinfection,
for example by chlorine, ozone, and UV treatment, which has a
high effectiveness in killing bacteria. However, toxic or
carcinogenic disinfection by-products (DBPs) are formed,
which have to be removed subsequently from the purified
water samples. The utilization of membranes can overcome this
problem by the retention of the bacteria cells at the filtering
layer and thus providing a permeate free from bacterial
contaminants and DBPs. The main advantage of membrane
technology is the fact that it works without the addition of
chemicals, with a relatively low energy use and straightforward
process handling.
12-15
However, membrane fouling is the most critical problem in
many membrane technology applications where fouling is often
mediated by biomolecules (e.g., proteins) or bioorganisms (e.g.,
fungi, bacteria, viruses). Fouling leads to a decline of permeate
flux making more frequent cleaning and replacement necessary,
which then increases operating costs.
16-19
Today, membranes for bacteria filtration providing a sterile
barrier with a cutoff of 200 nm are widely used for process
water and wastewater treatments in biotechnology, food
technology, and pharmaceutical technology. To improve the
antifouling behavior, antibacterial components that either kill or
prevent the growth of bacteria can be immobilized onto
membrane surfaces leading to self-cleaning matrices. For
example, antibacterial substances are silver-based agents (silver
ions and silver nanoparticles, respectively), antimicrobial
peptides (AMPs such as mellitin, cecropin A), proteins (e.g.,
lactoferrin), and enzymes (bacterial cell wall hydrolases such as
lysozyme).
20-24
Received: February 16, 2012
Revised: July 11, 2012
Accepted: July 24, 2012
Published: July 24, 2012
Article
pubs.acs.org/est
© 2012 American Chemical Society 8739 dx.doi.org/10.1021/es3006496 | Environ. Sci. Technol. 2012, 46, 8739-8747