Transfusion Medicine | ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Case report of a haemovigilance investigation using
phylogenetic analysis of HIV-1 in Brazil
A. R. Pinto,
1
A. Petry,
2
T. Gr¨ af,
1
R. Vandresen
2
& E. Kupek
3
1
Department of Microbiology, Immunology and Parasitology, Federal University of Santa Catarina (UFSC), Florian´ opolis, Brazil,
2
Centre
for Haematology and Haemotherapy of the State of Santa Catarina (HEMOSC), Florian´ opolis, Brazil, and
3
Department of Public Health,
Federal University of Santa Catarina (UFSC), Florian´ opolis, Brazil
Received 26 July 2011; accepted for publication 08 November 2011
SUMMARY
Objectives: The aim of this work is to provide the first report of a
transfusion-acquired HIV-1 infection and to verify transmission
from the donor to the recipients using phylogenetic analysis of
HIV-1 DNA sequences in a Brazilian blood bank.
Background: Although haemovigilance procedures based on
phylogenetic analysis of HIV have been reported in several
countries, this type of study has yet to be conducted in Latin
America.
Materials and Methods: Upon identifying a HIV-1-positive
repeat blood donor by enzyme immunoassay (EIA) blood
screening, all recipients of the donor’s previous donation were
identified and tested for HIV-1 by EIA, nucleic acid amplification
test and HIV-1 DNA sequencing and phylogenetic analysis.
Results: One of the recipients tested positive for HIV-1. The
phylogenetic analysis showed a high genetic similarity among
the viruses, thus supporting the hypothesis of transmission from
the donor to the recipient.
Conclusions: Phylogenetic analysis of HIV-1 DNA sequences
has been a decisive tool in verifying suspected transmission of
the virus from blood donor to recipient in Brazil.
Key words: blood donation, HIV, phylogenetic analysis,
transfusion.
Haemovigilance is a set of procedures aimed at improving
blood transfusion safety by reducing transfusion complications,
among which TRALI (transfusion-related acute lung injury)
has received particular attention (Flesland, 2007). In the 21st
century, significant advances have been made to better co-
ordinate haemovigilance systems in place, both within and
between the countries (Faber, 2009). Despite these efforts,
Correspondence: Emil Kupek, Department of Public Health/CCS,
Universidade Federal de Santa Catarina, 88040-900 Florianopolis-SC,
Brazil.
Tel.: +55 48 30256232; fax: +55 48 37219542;
e-mail: kupek@ccs.ufsc.br
under-reporting of transfusion complications is still a major
problem even in developed countries. In Brazil, the notification
of serious transfusion complications is mandatory. When a
health authority receives such notification, the Brazilian Ministry
of Health guidelines instruct the officials to contact the state
blood bank association which then initiates a haemovigilance
investigation (Minist´ erio de Sa ´ ude, 2003). First, blood bank
computerised donor records are searched to identify the donors
who donated the blood components involved in the transfusion
suspected to have caused the complications. Second, the donors
are verified for subsequent donations and possible positive
test results by serology screening. If no subsequent donation
took place, the donors are invited for serology testing at a
blood bank. For all investigations, suspected donors’ plasma,
which had been frozen at −20
◦
C following their last donation,
is submitted for serological testing. In the case of suspected
HIV transmission, these tests involve enzyme immunoassay
(EIA), Western blot and polymerase chain reaction (PCR)
for HIV.
In the last decade, Brazilian Ministry of Health has created two
computerised national databases for haemovigilance known as
SINEPS and HEMOVIGI, as well as an electronic publication of
the main results (Minist´ erio de Sa ´ ude, 2010). However, under-
reporting of transfusion complications was estimated to be 80%
in 2007 (Minist´ erio de Sa ´ ude, 2010). This may explain why
only three cases of transfusion-transmitted infectious diseases
have been reported in this source, despite high residual risk
estimates that suggest much higher figures (Kupek, 2001,
2004).
Despite significant technological advances in blood safety in
Brazil, such as recent introduction of nucleic acid amplification
test (NAT) techniques for blood screening in some blood
banks, a paucity of published research on haemovigilance
exists. Even well-established epidemiological studies based on
lookback methodology have been lacking in Brazil. The aim of
this work is to diminish the gap between recently established
technological advances in blood safety and their application
to haemovigilance in the country. To this end, we describe
an application of phylogenetic analysis of HIV-1 as means of
© 2011 The Authors First published online 2 December 2011
Transfusion Medicine © 2011 British Blood Transfusion Society doi: 10.1111/j.1365-3148.2011.01120.x