Explicit FE-Models and High Speed DIC
for Transient-Dynamics of Electronics
Pradeep Lall
2
, Dhananjay Panchagade
2
, Deepti Iyengar
2
,
Sandeep Shantaram
2
, Jeff Suhling
2
, Hubert Schrier
1
2
Auburn University
Department of Mechanical Engineering
and Center for Advanced Vehicle Electronics,
Auburn, AL 36849
1
Correlated Solutions, West Columbia, SC 29171
Tele: (334) 844-3424
E-mail: lall@eng.auburn.edu
ABSTRACT
Electronics may be subjected to shock, vibration, and drop-impact during shipping, handling and during normal usage.
Measurement of transient dynamic deformation of the electronics assemblies during the shock and vibration can yield
significant insights in understanding the occurrence of failure modes and the development of failure envelopes. Failure-modes
include solder-joint failures, pad cratering, chip-cracking, copper trace fracture, and underfill fillet failures. Previous
researchers have measured the transient-dynamics of board assemblies with high-speed imaging in conjunction with high-
speed image analysis for measurement of relative displacement, angle, velocity, and acceleration [Lall 2006, Che 2006]. In
addition, high-speed data-acquisition systems with discrete strain gages have been used for measurements of transient strain
[Lall 2004, 2005, Liang 2005] and with accelerometers for measurement of transient acceleration [Dunford 2004, Goyal 2000,
Seah 2005]. Development of accurate models requires better understanding of full-field strain deformation in board
assemblies.
In this paper, the use of digital image correlation (DIC) with ultra high-speed imaging has been used for full-field measurement
of transient strain in various board assemblies subjected to shock in various orientations. Measurements have been taken on
both the package and the board side of the assemblies. Accuracy of high-speed optical measurement has been compared
with that from discrete strain gages. Package architectures examined include-flex ball-grid arrays, tape-array ball-grid arrays,
and metal lead-frame packages. Explicit finite-element models have been developed and correlated with experimental data.
Models developed include, smeared property models, Timoshenko-beam models, and explicit sub-models. The solder strains
have been computed from the explicit finite element models for life prediction in shock.
INTRODUCTION
High speed photography has been used to measure deformation and strain in sheet metal forming analysis, automotive crash
testing, rail vehicle safety [Kirpatrick 2001], air-plane safety [Marzougui 1999], modal analysis of blades, disks, shearography
which involves laser NDT for rapid honeycomb delamination tests, dynamic fracture phenomenon, tire tests, rotating
components, exhaust manifolds, split Hopkinson bar tests, package integrity or hermiticity (MIL-STD-883) tests. High-speed
cameras measure impact speed, force, and deformation due to shock, and thermal loading. It is also used for quantitative
evaluation of in-plane deformation characteristics of geo-materials [Watanabe 2005], and in medical fields to assess local
failure of bone by implementing mechanical compression testing of bone samples [Thurner 2005].
Previously, the measurement of derivatives of field quantities, such as strains, was limited to a specific physical locations or
discrete target points in an electronic structure. It was not feasible to extract data at a very large number of locations by using
discrete targets because of the time-consuming process. Techniques such as Moiré Interferometry is an option to get the
overall deformation contour, but it is often time consuming and involves expensive grates. Digital Image Correlation (DIC) is
the state-of-art technique which super-cedes the later as it is less time consuming. The sample preparation is simple and
quick. The test specimens are speckle painted and transient deformation recorded with the help of high-speed cameras, to
enable the measurement of full-field strains. Feasibility of this technique has been explored in this paper and has been
experimented on electronic assemblies under free drop and constrained drop for the first time.