PSYCHO-ONCOLOGY
Psycho -Oncology 9: 232–242 (2000)
COUPLES DEALING WITH CANCER: ROLE AND
GENDER DIFFERENCES REGARDING
PSYCHOLOGICAL DISTRESS AND QUALITY OF
LIFE
MARIE T HAGEDOORN
a,
*, BRAM P. BUUNK
a
, ROELINE G. KUIJER
b
, THEO WOBBES
c
and
ROBBERT SANDERMAN
a
a
Uniersity of Groningen, Netherlands
b
Health Psychology, Utrecht Uniersity, Netherlands
c
Academic Hospital St. Radboud, Uniersity of Nijmegen, Netherlands
SUMMARY
The goal of the present study was to further knowledge on gender and role (i.e. patient versus partner) differences
in psychological distress and quality of life as a consequence of dealing with cancer. There is some evidence that
being the patient or the caregiver makes more difference for men than for women. In total, 173 couples facing
various forms of cancer (two samples) and a control group of 80 couples completed the CES-D and Cantril’s
Ladder. Analyses of variance revealed that both female patients and female partners of patients perceived more
psychological distress and a lower quality of life than women in healthy couples. In contrast, role did have an
effect on men. Specifically, male patients scored as high on psychological distress and as low on quality of life as
female patients and female partners, but psychological distress and quality of life did not differ between male
partners of patients and their healthy controls. However, this effect was found in only one patient sample. The
finding that female partners perceived more psychological distress and a lower quality of life than male partners
could not be accounted for by differences in the physical condition of the patient or the partner. Copyright © 2000
John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
INTRODUCTION
A severe illness, such as cancer, not only affects
lives of patients, but also the lives of those who
are close to them. Patients may become highly
psychologically distressed and may perceive a low
quality of life resulting from the fear of dying, a
worsening physical condition, painful treatments,
and side effects of such treatments. At the same
time, their partners may perceive psychological
distress and low quality of life because of the fear
of losing their loved one, and because of possible
burdens, such as the provision of care and sup-
port, and restrictions regarding their social life.
Not only do both partners have to deal with their
own emotions and problems resulting from the
illness, they also have to cope with each other’s
problems, emotions and fears (Coyne et al., 1990;
Coyne and Smith, 1991).
The findings on distress in cancer patients and
their partners are inconsistent. In several studies,
intimate partners were found to be as distressed as
patients (e.g. Northouse and Swain, 1987; Oberst
and Scott, 1988; Baider et al., 1996). In a study by
Given and Given (1992), husbands of patients
with recurrent breast cancer reported even more
depressive symptoms than their wives. However,
other studies among couples dealing with breast
cancer showed lower levels of distress for the
husbands than for the patients (Hoskins, 1995;
Northouse et al., 1998). Moreover, the current
literature in this area has a number of limitations.
First, couples’ adjustment to cancer has been
most frequently examined among patients with
breast cancer and their spouses. As a conse-
quence, it is impossible to conclude whether dif-
ferences in psychological distress and quality of
life between patients and partners are a result of
* Correspondence to: University of Groningen, Social and
Organizational Psychology, Grote Kruisstraat 2/I, 9712 TS
Groningen, Netherlands. Tel.: + 31 50 363 64 60/363 63 86;
e-mail: M.Hagedoorn@ppsw.rug.nl
Copyright © 2000 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Receied 28 June 1999
Accepted 6 March 2000