Elastic Property of Vertically Aligned
Nanowires
Jinhui Song,
²
Xudong Wang,
²
Elisa Riedo,*
,‡
and Zhong L. Wang*
,²
School of Materials Science and Engineering and School of Physics, Georgia Institute
of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia 30332-0245
Received July 12, 2005; Revised Manuscript Received August 22, 2005
ABSTRACT
An atomic force microscopy (AFM) based technique is demonstrated for measuring the elastic modulus of individual nanowires/nanotubes
aligned on a solid substrate without destructing or manipulating the sample. By simultaneously acquiring the topography and lateral force
image of the aligned nanowires in the AFM contacting mode, the elastic modulus of the individual nanowires in the image has been derived.
The measurement is based on quantifying the lateral force required to induce the maximal deflection of the nanowire where the AFM tip was
scanning over the surface in contact mode. For the [0001] ZnO nanowires/nanorods grown on a sapphire surface with an average diameter
of 45 nm, the elastic modulus is measured to be 29 ± 8 GPa.
Characterizing the mechanical properties of nanowiress/
nanotubes/nanorods (NWs/NTs/NRs) is of great importance
for their applications in electronics, optoelectronics, sensors,
and actuators. There are several techniques that have been
developed for measuring the elastic properties of individual
NTs. The technique demonstrated by Lieber et al.
1
was based
on quantifying the deflection of a carbon NT that was affixed
at one end and the other end was free to be deflected by an
atomic force microscope tip. The NT was laid in parallel to
a solid substrate, and the elastic modulus of a carbon NT
was calculated from the force-deflection curve. A technique
by Wang et al.
2,3
relied on the electromechanical resonance
of a NT/NW by in situ transmission electron microscopy
(TEM). The resonance was stimulated by applying ac voltage
across two electrodes, one of which was a carbon NT that
was glued to a metal tip affixed on a specimen holder. The
resonance frequency together with the geometrical parameters
of the NT provided by TEM yielded the elastic modulus.
The technique of Yu et al.
4
used two atomic force microscope
tips to stretch a carbon NT that was glued at both ends to
the two tips, respectively; the stretching force-displacement
curve gave tensile strength and elastic modulus. A technique
developed by Salvetat et al.
5,6
used an atomic force micro-
scope tip to bend a NT or a bundle of single-walled NTs
lying across a hole in a solid substrate. Quantifying the
thermal vibration amplitude of a NT in TEM also yielded
its elastic modulus.
7
Atomic force microscopy (AFM) has
also been applied to study the transversal elasticity of NTs.
8
For all of these techniques, the NTs have to be removed
from the substrate used in the growth and are manipulated
for the measurements.
Growth of aligned NTs/NWs is of great importance for
many technological applications. Elastic properties of densely
aligned carbon NTs have been measured by an “indentation”
method,
9
in which a tip was pushed downward against the
aligned NTs so that many NTs are in contact with the tip
and its side surface. By measurment of the force-displace-
ment curve, and the average number of NTs that were in
contact with the tip and the contacting area of the NTs with
the tip, an average elastic modulus of the NTs was received.
This method requires that the density of the nanotubes is
high and all of the nanotubes have the same size and length,
and the measured result is a statistical average of all the NTs.
In this paper, we demonstrate an alternative AFM based
technique for measuring the elastic properties of individual
aligned ZnO NWs in scanning area. By simultaneously
recording the topography and lateral force image in AFM
contact mode when the AFM tip scans across the aligned
nanowire arrays, the elastic modulus of individual NWs is
determined. This technique allows a measurement of the
mechanical properties of individual NWs of different lengths
in an aligned array without destructing or manipulating the
sample.
The aligned ZnO NW arrays were grown using gold as
catalyst by a vapor-liquid-solid method (VLS) process, as
reported previously.
10
By choice of an appropriate substrate,
the epitaxial growth of ZnO on the single-crystal substrate,
such as R-Al
2
O
3
, GaN, AlN, or Al
0.5
Ga
0.5
N,
11
yields aligned
ZnO nanowires. Figure 1a shows a scanning electron
microscopy (SEM) image of the as-grown ZnO nanowires
on an R-Al
2
O
3
substrate, showing well-aligned distribution
* Corresponding authors. E-mail: zhong.wang@mse.gatech.edu (Z.L.W.);
elisa.riedo@physics.gatech.edu (E.R.).
²
School of Materials Science and Engineering.
‡
School of Physics.
NANO
LETTERS
2005
Vol. 5, No. 10
1954-1958
10.1021/nl051334v CCC: $30.25 © 2005 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 09/01/2005