Corpus callosum: musician and gender e¡ects
Dennis J. Lee,
1,2
Yi Chen
1
and Gottfried Schlaug
1,CA
1
DepartmentofNeurology,BethIsraelDeaconessMedicalCenterandHarvardMedicalSchool,330BrooklineAve,Boston,MA02215;
2
FacultyofArtsandSciences,HarvardCollege,HarvardUniversity,Cambridge,MA02138,USA
CA
CorrespondingAuthor:gschlaug@caregroup.harvard.edu
Received5September2002; accepted11December2002
DOI:10.1097/01.wnr.0000053761.76853.41
Previously we found that musicians have signi¢cantly larger ante-
riorcorpuscallosum(CC).Inthecurrentstudy,weintendedtore-
plicate and extend our previous results using a new and larger
sample of gender-matched subjects (56 right-handed professional
musicians and 56 age- and handedness-matched controls). We
found a signi¢cantgender musicianship interaction for anterior
and posterior CC size; male musicians had a larger anterior CC
thannon-musicians,whilefemalesdidnotshowasigni¢cante¡ect
of musicianship.The lack of a signi¢cant e¡ect in females may be
due to a tendency for a more symmetric brain organization and a
disproportionately high representation of absolutepitch (AP) mu-
sicians among females. Although a direct causal e¡ect between
musicianship and alterations in the midsagittal CC size cannot be
established, itis likely that the earlycommencement and continu-
ouspracticeofbimanualmotor trainingservesasanexternaltrig-
ger that can in£uence midsagittal CC size through changes in the
actualcallosal¢bercompositionandinthedegreeofmyelinization,
which will have implications for interhemispheric connectivity.
NeuroReport 14:205^209 c 2003LippincottWilliams&Wilkins.
Key words: Absolutepitch;Corpuscallosum;Gender;Laterality;Magneticresonanceimaging;Motor skills;Music;Plasticity
INTRODUCTION
The corpus callosum (CC), the main band of interhemi-
spheric axonal fibers in the human brain, performs a key
role in the transferal and integration of information between
the two hemispheres. Group differences in midsagittal
callosal area are generally regarded as neuroanatomic
correlates for large-scale differences in interhemispheric
connectivity and brain asymmetry [1–3]. It has been shown
that midsagittal callosal size correlates with the number of
fibers passing through the CC [4], and that the corpus
callosum is one of the last main fiber tracts to mature in
humans [5]. Increases in CC size have been observed
through in vivo imaging until at least the third decade of
human life, with maximal growth in the first decade [6,7].
As this period of presumed callosal maturation coincides
with childhood increases in synaptic density and fine tuning
of the neural organization [8,9], it has been proposed that
environmental stimuli, especially early in life, might
affect callosal development [10]. Animal experiments have
provided evidence that differential rearing affects CC size
[11].
Extensive musical training, commencing at an early age
and continued through life, provides exactly such extra-
ordinary environmental stimuli. Professional musicians,
defined as those who are performers, music teachers, or
conservatory-level music students, often begin training at an
early age, and practice their instruments daily, sometimes
up to several hours a day, from childhood throughout their
adult lives.
In a previous study, we demonstrated group differences
between musicians and non-musicians in the anterior CC,
with early-beginning musicians displaying a significantly
larger midsagittal anterior CC area [10]. We hypothesized
that the increased midsagittal CC size in musicians might be
evidence for externally triggered changes in the anatomical
composition of the CC. These results were astonishing
considering that only a few human studies have found
structural brain differences between two groups of subjects
as a function of certain skills or intense practice [12]. Animal
experiments have provided a wealth of data that structural
changes as a function of motor training can be seen [13]. In
this study, we intended to replicate our previous results
using a new, larger, and gender-balanced sample in order to
examine possible differences in the CC size between
musicians and non-musicians and to determine whether
an interaction exist between musicianship and gender as has
been found in other studies.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Subjects: Our group of subjects consisted of 56 healthy
musicians (28 males, 28 females) and 56 healthy non-
musician controls matched for age. Due to the possible effect
of handedness on midsagittal CC size [2,3], we selected only
right-handed subjects. Our subjects were retrospectively
selected from a prospective database of high-resolution
anatomical MR scans of musicians and non-musicians.
Subjects participated in various research protocols, which
0959-4965 c LippincottWilliams&Wilkins Vol 14 No 2 10 February 2003 205
MOTORSYSTEMS NEUROREPORT
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.