ARTICLE IN PRESS
Applied Ocean Research ( ) –
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Applied Ocean Research
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/apor
Application of a vortex tracking method to the piston-like behaviour in a
semi-entrained vertical gap
T. Kristiansen
∗
, O.M. Faltinsen
Centre for Ships and Offshore Structures (CeSOS), Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU), N-7491, Trondheim, Norway
Department of Marine Technology, Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU), N-7491, Trondheim, Norway
article info
Article history:
Received 4 December 2007
Accepted 18 February 2008
Available online xxxx
Keywords:
Vortex tracking method
Boundary layer effect
Numerical wavetank
Moonpool
abstract
Near resonance the piston mode amplitude in semi-entrained volumes of fluid such as in moonpools or
in between a ship and a terminal may become large relative to the level of excitation. Linear theory is
known to over-predict the fluid response in these types of systems significantly, suffering from the lack
of damping whose only manifestation is radiated waves. In reality, however, viscous effects may act as
damping and nonlinear effects associated with the free surface conditions may cause transfer of energy
between the different modes. In the present work, which is within the framework of potential theory,
a fully nonlinear numerical wavetank based on Green’s 2nd identity coupled with an inviscid vortex
tracking method is applied to the moonpool problem. The paper presents a methodology for perpetual
simplification of the free shear layer as the system undergoes near sinusoidal motion in order to reach
steady state. This is practically impossible without such simplifications due to the otherwise exceedingly
complex wake structures evolving only after the first one or two periods. Also the in- and out-flow of the
boundary layers are modelled. The results are compared to experiments. In the investigated cases models
of rectangular shape with sharp corners provide well-defined separation points, and such sharp corners
are in practice introduced e.g. by bilge keels. It is found that: (1) The damping effect associated with the
nonlinear free surface conditions are of minor importance, (2) the effect of the in- and out-flow of the
boundary layer is negligible to all practical purposes, whereas (3) the flow separation explains the major
part of the discrepancy between the measured response and that estimated by linear theory.
© 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
The water motion in a semi-entrained volume of fluid with
a free surface may experience resonant behaviour with respect
to the different possible free surface modes when undergoing
external forcing among which the lowest mode, often referred
to as the piston mode and corresponding to the vertical motion
of the mean free surface has drawn the attention of several
authors, including [1–3]. The main focus in these works was, in
the framework of linear potential theory, to identify the resonance
frequencies of the piston mode. The piston mode amplitude was
also investigated. Near resonance the piston mode amplitude may
become large relative to the amplitude of the exciting mechanism,
with the consequence of among other things large forces on the
structures actually defining the semi-entrained volume. However,
linear theory is known to over-predict the fluid response with
respect to experimental results in such semi-entrained systems. In
practice this has been remedied by introducing artificial damping
∗
Corresponding author. Tel.: +47 73595629; fax: +47 73595528.
E-mail address: trygve.kristiansen@ntnu.no (T. Kristiansen).
coefficients in the free surface conditions, with the values tuned
from e.g. model test results. However, the introduction of such
artificial damping coefficients is purely empirical and not based
on physical reasoning. It is a pragmatic approach taken due to the
yet poorly understood mechanism for the discrepancy. Therefore,
an investigation of the physical mechanisms contributing to the
discrepancy is of interest, and we feel that the present work
provides new insight into the matter.
In principle, the attention of the present discussion is on
any arrangement consisting of a well-defined vertical gap, or
inner domain of some sort connected with an outer domain
allowing radiated waves to escape. Practical examples of such
semi-entrained systems are moonpools (vertical openings through
the decks of ships), ship-by-ship operations or a ship by a terminal.
The results in the present work are directly compared to the results
in [3] where they investigated piston-like sloshing in a moonpool,
or similarly, in between the hulls of a catamaran.
In terms of a linear mass–spring system the response is
sensitive to the magnitude of the damping when this is small.
Linearly, only wave radiation contributes to damping while in
reality, two additional mechanisms may affect the piston mode
motion. The first being the effects of viscosity. Assuming high
Reynolds numbers this includes in- and out-flow of boundary
0141-1187/$ – see front matter © 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.apor.2008.02.003
Please cite this article in press as: Kristiansen T, Faltinsen OM. Application of a vortex tracking method to the piston-like behaviour in a semi-entrained vertical gap.
Applied Ocean Research (2008), doi:10.1016/j.apor.2008.02.003