ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Changes in Body Image and Health-Related Quality of Life
Following Breast Reduction Surgery in German
Macromastia Patients
A New Tool for Measuring Body Image Changes
Ada Borkenhagen, PhD,* Frank Ro ¨hricht, MD, MRCPsych,† Simone Preiß,‡
Wolfgang Schneider,‡ and Elmar Bra ¨hler*
Abstract: Health insurance funds in Germany are increasingly
reluctant to fund the cost for reduction mammaplasty. However,
several studies have already demonstrated the beneficial effects of
breast reduction on symptom relief and health-related quality of life.
More specifically, the psychologic and social consequences of breast
reduction surgery were also recently evaluated. Relating to the
contemporary debate on financial restraint, the present article de-
scribes a follow-up study conducted in a sample of 40 patients
undergoing reduction mammaplasty. The purpose of the investiga-
tion was to assess indicators of health-related quality of life follow-
ing reduction mammaplasty. Furthermore, the study aimed to assess
body image changes and to test a new assessment instrument,
Digital-Body-Photo-Test (DBPT), in comparison with a well-vali-
dated body image measure (Color-a-Person Body Dissatisfaction
Test, CAPT) (concurrent validity). As hypothesized, the findings
indicate significant improvements in health-related quality-of-life
measures and body-image characteristics. The substantial improve-
ment of body-image satisfaction of all body areas suggests a gen-
eralized positive effect of reduction mammaplasty on overall body
image. The strong association between the DBPT and the CAPT
scores in this study indicates that DBPT is an efficient and valid new
tool for measuring body-image changes relating to patients’ evalu-
ations of their average satisfaction of specific body parts or areas and
their overall appearance acceptance.
Key Words: body image, reduction mammaplasty, health-related
quality of life, self-esteem, surgery outcomes
(Ann Plast Surg 2007;58: 000 – 000)
R
eduction mammaplasty is one of the most common pro-
cedures in plastic surgery. In contrast to the United States,
there is no valid information about the number of breast
reductions performed in Germany. Experts guess that about
30,000 breast reductions were performed in Germany per
year. Unfortunately, rejection of insurance coverage and
policy exclusions for breast reduction are becoming increas-
ingly common in Germany.
1
More often, reduction mamma-
plasty is seen as a purely cosmetic operation by the German
health insurance funds. According to the definition of recon-
structive surgery by the American Society of Plastic Surgeons
(ASPS), reduction mammaplasty is considered reconstructive
in nature. Women who seek reduction mammaplasty are
primarily interested in having average-sized breasts that are
proportional to the rest of their bodies.
2
The improved phys-
ical and psychosocial functioning that leads to an enhanced
quality of life has to be seen as an additional benefit of
reduction mammaplasty. Accordingly, several studies in re-
cent years revealed positive changes in body image and
increase in self-esteem in patients following reduction mam-
maplasty.
2
But studies investigating the outcome and the
implications on psychosocial functioning of German women
undergoing reduction mammaplasty are very rare.
3
Health-Related Quality of Life, Mood,
Complaints, and Body Image in Patients With
Macromastia
The majority of reduction mammaplasty patients
present with physical complaints ranging from neck, shoul-
der, and upper back pain to the inability to perform daily or
work-related activities. Most empirical studies describe a
high satisfaction rate after reduction mammaplasty. Signifi-
cant improvements in emotional, psychologic, and physical
well-being
2,4 –13
were reported by patients who underwent
bilateral breast reduction. In a meta-analysis of published
studies, Chadbourne et al
13
reported that current evidence
suggests that women undergoing reduction mammaplasty
have significant postoperative improvement of symptoms and
quality of life.
Jones and Bain
11
found in their review of studies
14 –18
on the benefits of reduction mammaplasty consistent im-
Received March 22, 2006, and accepted for publication, after revision, July
21, 2006.
From the *Department of Medical Psychology and Medical Sociology,
University of Leipzig, Leipzig, Germany; †Queen Mary University of
London, Newham Centre for Mental Health, London, UK; and the
‡Clinic of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Otto-von-Guericke-Uni-
versity of Magdeburg, Magdeburg, Germany.
Reprints: Ada Borkenhagen, PhD, University of Leipzig, Department of
Medical Psychology and Medical Sociology, Stephanstr. 11, 04103
Leipzig, Germany. E-mail: Dr.Borkenhagen@web.de.
Copyright © 2007 by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
ISSN: 0148-7043/07/5804-0001
DOI: 10.1097/01.sap.0000239840.62931.52
balt5/zps-aps/zps-aps/zps00407/zps4213-07z xppws S1 12/30/06 9:56 Art: SAP200537
Annals of Plastic Surgery • Volume 58, Number 4, April 2007 1
AQ: 1
AQ: 7