0041-1337/99/6706-915/0
TRANSPLANTATION Vol. 67, 915–934, No. 6, March 27, 1999
Copyright © 1999 by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc. Printed in U.S.A.
Transplantation
BRIEF COMMUNICATIONS
SUCCESSFUL LIVING RELATED SIMULTANEOUS PANCREAS-
KIDNEY TRANSPLANT BETWEEN IDENTICAL TWINS
ENRICO BENEDETTI,
1,2
TY DUNN,
1
MALEK G. MASSAD,
1
VANDAD RAOFI,
1
AMELIA BARTHOLOMEW,
1
RAINER W. G. GRUESSNER,
3
AND CAROLYN BRECKLIN
4
Departments of Surgery and Medicine, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, and Department of Surgery,
University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
Simultaneous pancreas-kidney transplant from liv-
ing donors has been recently proposed as an effective
therapeutic option in selected uremic patients with
type I diabetes. We report the first simultaneous pan-
creas-kidney transplant performed between identical
twins. Posttransplant, the recipient has been main-
tained on low dose cyclosporine to avoid recurrent
auto-immune insulitis. At the 1-year follow-up, both
donor and recipient are well with normal renal func-
tion and excellent glucose control. Simultaneous pan-
creas-kidney transplant between identical twins can
be performed successfully using cyclosporine to pre-
vent recurrent auto-immune insulitis.
The first successful kidney transplant, performed by Mur-
ray in 1954, was a living related renal transplant between
identical twins (ITs*) (1). Since this landmark case, different
organs and tissues have been successfully transplanted be-
tween ITs, including bowel (2), pancreas (3), bone marrow (4),
and parathyroid (5). We report the first case of simultaneous
pancreas-kidney transplant (SPK) between ITs, performed to
cure end-stage renal failure caused by type I diabetes.
CASE REPORT
The patient is a 38-year-old African American female with
history of insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus who was ini-
tially recognized to have renal failure when she presented
with menorrhagia in July 1996. At that time, her serum
creatinine was 2.5 mg/dl and she was noted to have protein-
uria. She had already been diagnosed with diabetic retinop-
athy and had undergone laser photocoagulation to her right
eye. Her serum creatinine was noted to rise progressively,
and she was referred to our nephrology service by her pri-
mary care physician. Her past medical history was signifi-
cant for insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus since age 19,
when she presented with symptomatic hyperglycemia during
her freshman year of college. Her surgical history included
appendectomy, total abdominal hysterectomy, and left vitrec-
tomy. She had no family history of diabetes. At the time of
evaluation, she was taking the following medications: nifed-
ipine, captopril, furosemide, iron, and insulin. Physical ex-
amination was significant for a blood pressure of 144/94
mmHg, normal cardiovascular exam, and marked bilateral
pitting edema of the lower extremities. There was evidence of
early peripheral neuropathy. Urinalysis was significant for
trace blood and proteinuria; urine sediment showed oval fat
bodies and maltese crosses. Serum creatinine was 3.3 mg/dl
and 24 hr urine protein was 4.4 g. The hemoglobin was 7.8
g/dl with mean corpuscular volume of 90 m
3
and a white
blood count of 4,800/mm
3
. Serum albumin was 3.5 g/dl, cal-
cium 8.8 mg/dl, and phosphate 4.0 mg/dl. She was negative
for anti-islet and anti-insulin antibodies, and her C-peptide
levels were undetectable. A renal ultrasound demonstrated
normal size kidneys with normal echotexture. Despite good
blood pressure and glucose control, her renal disease pro-
gressed; she was therefore referred for transplantation. Stan-
dard pretransplant evaluation confirmed that she was an
excellent candidate for SPK. Because she had a nondiabetic
IT as a potential donor, a living related kidney and pancreas
transplant was considered. Standard HLA typing confirmed
that the donor and recipient had identical HLA phenotype
(A
3,30
;B
35,49
;C
w4,w7
;DR
4,18
;DQ
3,4
). Mixed lymphocyte culture
between the donor and the recipient was mutually nonreac-
tive. Donor work-up included negative anti-islet antibody
and anti-insulin antibody assays. Furthermore, baseline
fasting insulin levels and oral glucose tolerance test were
normal. A preoperative abdominal spiral computed tomo-
graphic scan of the donor defined the presence of normal
anatomy of the left kidney (single artery and vein).
After extensive discussion with both the donor and the
recipient, the decision was made to proceed with a preemp-
tive SPK. Inasmuch as the recipient’s creatinine had risen to
10 mg/dl, the procedure was carried out without further
delay.
Donor operation. Through a midline incision, the left kid-
ney was initially procured in the standard fashion and im-
mediately transported to the recipient operating room for
transplantation. Then, the tail and body of the donor pan-
creas were surgically exposed and dissected free (Fig. 1). The
1
Department of Surgery, University of Illinois at Chicago.
2
Address correspondence to: Enrico Benedetti, M.D., Department
of Surgery, Division of Transplantation, 840 South Wood Street, M/C
958, Chicago, IL 60612.
3
Department of Surgery, University of Zurich.
4
Department of Medicine, University of Illinois at Chicago.
* Abbreviations: IT, identical twin; SPK, simultaneous pancreas-
kidney transplant.
915