On the Mechanism of Homogeneous Decomposition of the Chlorinated Silanes. Chain
Reactions Propagated by Divalent Silicon Species
Mark T. Swihart* and Robert W. Carr
Department of Chemical Engineering and Materials Science, UniVersity of Minnesota,
Minneapolis, Minnesota 55455
ReceiVed: September 30, 1997; In Final Form: January 6, 1998
A mechanism for the homogeneous gas-phase decomposition of SiHCl
3
, SiH
2
Cl
2
, and SiH
3
Cl in hydrogen is
derived from the results of ab initio molecular-orbital studies. It consists of 39 reversible elementary reactions
among 25 species, including pressure-dependent unimolecular decomposition of the chlorinated silanes and
secondary chemistry due to reactions of SiH
2
, SiHCl, and SiCl
2
with one another and with the chlorinated
silanes. Rate parameters in the mechanism have been calculated based on results of ab initio studies using
transition-state theory and unimolecular rate theories. This allows us to construct a reasonably complete
mechanism that provides qualitative explanations for several features of dichlorosilane decomposition that
have been presented in the literature, including observations on the presence and concentrations of SiCl
2
,
SiHCl, and Si atoms. Several chain reactions in which the chain carriers are divalent silicon species have
been identified.
Introduction
The chlorinated silanes, particularly dichlorosilane and trichlo-
rosilane, are used as precursors for the chemical vapor deposition
(CVD) of epitaxial silicon. At the high temperatures where this
process is carried out, homogeneous decomposition of the parent
molecules may play an important role by generating reactive
species that lead to film growth. Secondary reactions can both
accelerate the decomposition of the precursor and consume
reactive intermediates that could otherwise lead to film growth.
To understand the mechanisms of film growth and develop
detailed, physically based models of silicon epitaxy from the
chlorinated silanes, we must be able to assess which, if any,
homogeneous reactions are likely to be important at the reactor
conditions and what the rates of these reactions are. This has
not, so far, been possible for silicon epitaxy from dichlorosilane
or trichlorosilane. Here, we present a reaction mechanism and
rate parameters for the homogeneous thermal decomposition
of the chlorinated silanes. The mechanism is applicable to
homogeneous decomposition of SiH
3
Cl, SiH
2
Cl
2
, and SiHCl
3
in H
2
. Silane decomposition mechanisms are understood in
more detail and have been presented and discussed elsewhere.
1-3
Additional chemical species and reactions would be required
to describe SiCl
4
decomposition.
A number of observations on thermal decomposition of the
chlorosilanes have been published, but rate parameters and
decomposition mechanisms have not been experimentally
established. Laser pyrolysis of trichlorosilane
4
was observed
to give HCl and a white powder that was assumed to result
from SiCl
2
polymerization. Rate parameters were obtained and
were presumed to correspond to the elementary reaction SiHCl
3
f SiCl
2
+ HCl. There are several observations of dichlorosi-
lane decomposition in the literature, but both the rate parameters
and the primary reaction products still remain somewhat unclear.
In IR multiphoton dissociation experiments, Sausa and Ronn
5
detected electronically excited SiCl
2
. Walker et al.
6
decomposed
monochlorosilane and trichlorosilane in static bulb experiments,
and dichlorosilane both in static pyrolysis experiments and using
a single-pulse shock tube. They concluded that the initial
dichlorosilane decomposition products were SiCl
2
and H
2
, based
partially on the fact that very little HCl was observed as a
product in their shock-tube experiments. They interpreted their
experimental results in terms of a reaction mechanism that
differs in some respects from the one presented here. On the
basis of that mechanism, they obtain rate parameters for the
three decompositions. Kruppa, Shin, and Beauchamp
7
found
that SiCl
2
and HCl were the primary products of vacuum flash
pyrolysis of SiH
2
Cl
2
. Ban and Gilbert
8
observed SiCl
2
by mass
spectrometry under silicon CVD conditions, and Ho and
Breiland
9
observed SiHCl by laser-induced fluorescence in a
silicon CVD reactor. Ho, Breiland, and Carr
10
observed that
193-nm photolysis of SiH
2
Cl
2
produced SiHCl. In pulsed laser-
powered homogeneous pyrolysis experiments,
11
we measured
reaction rates consistent with an activation energy for unimo-
lecular decomposition near 75 kcal/mol but were unable to
identify the primary reaction products.
Ab initio calculations
12,13
predict that the dominant unimo-
lecular decomposition path for dichlorosilane is SiH
2
Cl
2
f
SiHCl + HCl, with an activation energy near 75 kcal/mol. CVD
reactor models that included reactions in the gas phase
14,15
have
assumed that the reaction was SiH
2
Cl
2
f SiCl
2
+ H
2
. These
models also used rate parameters that gave reaction rates that
were orders of magnitude larger than the rates of the unimo-
lecular decomposition reactions predicted from the ab initio
calculations. This apparent discrepancy could be partially
resolved if there are secondary reactions in the gas phase that
accelerate the overall decomposition and convert SiHCl to SiCl
2
.
Consideration of such mechanisms can also shed light on the
varied experimental observations of dichlorosilane decomposi-
tion and on related processes in the decomposition of monochlo-
rosilane and trichlorosilane.
In this work, we present a mechanism and rate parameters
based on ab initio calculations for the unimolecular decomposi-
tion reactions of the chlorinated silanes and subsequent second-
1542 J. Phys. Chem. A 1998, 102, 1542-1549
S1089-5639(97)03174-5 CCC: $15.00 © 1998 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 02/11/1998