2012 2nd IEEE International Conference on Parallel, Distributed nd Grid Computing
Metrics Improvement ofMANET Using Reactive
Protocols Approach
Puneet Dadral
Department of Elecronics
Technology, Guru Nanak Dev
University, Amritsar, Punjab, India
puneet6 _dadral@yahoo.co.in
Rajan Vohra*
Department of Elecronics
Technology, Guru Nanak Dev
University, Amritsar, Punjab, India
sargam _lll@yahoo.co.in*
Ravinder Singh Sawhney
Department of Elecronics
Technology, Guru Nanak Dev
University, Amritsar, Punjab, India
sawhney_gndu@hotmail.com
Abstract- Mobile ad hoc networks (MANETs) are a
collection of wireless nodes that dynamically create a
wireless network among themselves without any
infrastructure. Each device in a MANET is free to move
independently in any direction, and will therefore change
its links to other devices frequently. The objective of this
paper is to evaluate the simulation of MANET reactive
routing protocols that are Ad Hoc On demand Distance
Vector (AODV) and Dynamic Source Routing (DSR) and
temporally ordered routing algorithm (TORA) for Guru
Nanak Dev University Campus environment using the High
Resolution Video Conferencing application. Comparative
analysis has been carried out based on the results obtained
by simulations with OFDM (802.11a) and Extended Rate
PHY (802.11g) physical characteristics in OPNET Modeler
version 14.5. Parameters used are Throughput, End to End
delay, Routing load and Media Access Delay.
Kywords- MANET, DSR, AOD, RREP, RREQ, A,
OPNET
I. INTRODUCTION
Mobile Ad hoc Networks refer to wireless networks
where all network components are mobile. In MANET
there is no distinction between a host and a router since
all network hosts can be endpoints as well as forwarders
of trafic [I]. Nodes in the network should be able to
sense and discover their neighboring nodes and interact
with them. Due to the limited transmission range of
wireless network interfaces, multiple network hops may
be needed for one node to exchange data with another
across the network. Nodes in these networks carry out
both network control and routing duties and thus
generate both user and application traics.
The nodes in the network are used to provide
connectivity and services that the nodes communicate
directly with one another in peer-to-peer fashion [2].
MANETS are successful in applications such as disaster
recovery, conferences, emergency situations in hospitals,
meetings, crowd control, and battle ields [3].
II. LITERATURE REVIEW
A lot of research work has been done previously for the
comparison analysis of routing protocols of MANET by
means of performance parameters for the various
978-1-4673-2925-5/12/$31.00 ©2012 IEEE 73
applications and used different simulators for this
purpose.
M.L Sharma, Noor Fatima Rizvi [4] have worked on
evaluating the performance of proactive and reactive
AODV, DSR routing protocols based on trafic
generators like FTP under different network scenarios
and the results are varied depending upon the used
raic. Results show that DSR performs better than
AODV in terms of packet delivery ratio and throughput
but worst in average end to end delay. While AODV
shows the best performance in terms of average end to
end delay and routing message overhead.
The research carried by Jahangir khan et al. [5] is to
extend and evaluate routing protocols AODV and DSR
in order to judge MANET delay and packet delivery
ratio in intermediate nodes and also to present some of
the undamental routing issues when developing QoS
(Quality of Service) ramework for ad hoc networks.
Maashri et al. [6] analyzed the performance of DSR,
AODV and OLSR routing protocols. The paper
concluded that DSR has superior performance in terms
of data packet delivery ratio, throughput and end to end
delay at the speeds of less than 10 mls compared to
AODV and OLSR. But, OLSR performed weak in the
presence of a statistically self-similar trafic at high
mobility especially in terms of data packet delivery ratio,
overhead and delay. Also in AODV, lower end-to-end
delay has been observed. Singla and P. Kakar [7] have
compared the performance of AODV, TORA and DSDV
protocols under both CBR and TCP traic pattern.
Simulation results show that Reactive protocols perform
better in terms of packet delivery ratio and average end
to end delay.
In our research, simulation results are evaluated for
AODV, DSR and TORA reactive protocols of MANET
based on OFDM (802.1Ia) and Extended Rate PHY
(802.11g) physical characteristics using high resolution
Video Conferencing application at high data rate of
48mbps.
III. PROTOCOLS DESCIPTION
A routing protocol is mainly used to discover the
shortest and most eficient path during the data
transmissions in MANET. Routing basically classiied in